Tony Blair and America undersiege, blogging

• Article
• Comments ()
• Click-2-Listen

By

My summer holiday starts on Wednesday, and quite frankly, it can't come a moment too soon. Trying to make sense of the anti-war campaign, the controversy over the British Broadcasting Corporation and the latest attacks on Tony Blair has been so bewildering that I cannot decide whether I am a patient on a psychiatric ward or whether I am just visiting.

That particular cloud has been following me around for quite a while now. Just a few months after September 11, for instance, I had a polite dinner party conversation with a B.B.C. luminary who took the standard anti-American line on international affairs. What seemed to distress him more than anything, though, was the fact that the world and its neighbor had taken to strolling around in that time-honored emblem of U.S. power, blue jeans.

Now there are, of course, all sorts of aesthetic arguments for and against these jeans (I happen to like them, with or without cowboy boots), but if you are going to denounce them as a symbol of global capitalism, it is probably a good idea to make sure you are not wearing a pair at the time. The man from the Beeb had clearly forgotten to check below his waistband. And a very nice, expensive-looking pair of denims they were too.

But then, as he explained when I pointed out this slight, um, inconsistency, it was safe for him to wear them: He was much more concerned about the manipulation of "the masses" (yes, there are people who still use that hoary old Marxist term) than educated middle-class people like himself. At this point I realized there was no point pursuing the argument unless I was willing to get into a fight, and to be honest even at that early stage in the new world order I was tired of arguing. Logic makes little impression on the anti-U.S. camp. Either you sign up with their conventional wisdom or you are guilty of thought crime. There is no middle ground.

In the end, you can only trust your eyes and ears. When I watched Tony Blair's speech to Congress I came away feeling it was a decent speech by a decent man. But I must have been wrong, because a day or two later, listening to a discussion on B.B.C. radio, I heard a respected newspaper columnist describe the Prime Minister as "near-psychopathic". No one, I noticed, around the table sprang to Mr. Blair's defense. When I picked up the latest issue of the left-wing weekly The New Statesman, I found one of its main articles gave a group of psychiatrists and psychologists the opportunity to put the prime minister on the couch.

"One view emerged strongly," the article declared. "There appears to be something worryingly adrift in the mind of Anthony Charles Lynton Blair, a man who doesn't really know who or what he is. More technically, he is diagnosed as a psychopath capable of reinventing himself with remarkable dexterity, like an actor."

So much for rational debate. It's to Tony Blair's enormous credit that he has been willing to try to engage the enemy in a grownup conversation. So far it has not done him much good (even the Tories are debasing themselves by cashing in on the postwar hysteria). I fully expect him to have the last word once Saddam and his WMDs are finally run to ground, but in the meantime, it would be nice to think that he was getting more concentrated support from Washington.

Speeches to joint houses of Congress certainly play well in the States, but they look less impressive to a skeptical British public which still largely sees the world through the distorted prism of a B.B.C. bulletin. Much as I admire George Bush, I have to admit that presidential asides about the "bad people" in Guantanamo Bay make Mr. Blair's job even more difficult. America should be winning all the big arguments on this side of the Atlantic, but at the moment it is losing them by default simply because it is not making enough of an effort to state its case.

All the nostalgic talk of the WWII alliance and the Anglosphere is blinding Washington opinion-formers to the uncomfortable truth that Middle Britain, and the middle classes especially, can no longer automatically be counted as allies. What is needed is not so much a propaganda offensive as an attempt to convey the basic facts about the United States' role as the world's leading liberal democracy. Ignorance about American history and politics runs very deep here. Anti-Americans, on both left and right, are making the biggest noise. But noise is all it is. It is time to demonstrate that the Emperor has no clothes -- except, that is, for a secondhand pair of blue jeans.