


SAN JOSE, Calif. - Executives from Silicon Valley to Wall Street are adamant that shifting white-collar jobs from the United States to developing countries is good business, but a backlash is brewing.
Indiana’s state government canceled a $15 million contract with an Indian consulting firm in November. And eight states, including Maryland, voted on bills last year that would ban the use of taxpayer money on contracts with foreign workers. Though none of those measures passed, the states and several others are expected to consider similar bills this year.
Democratic presidential candidate John Kerry says he would require overseas call centers to disclose their location — the New Economy version of the “made in America” label.
The Massachusetts senator said he wouldn’t ban outsourcing, but would provide tax credits to companies that maintain U.S. factories and “close every single loophole that gives companies incentives to move jobs abroad.”
Outsourcing critics say Americans have been complacent about the loss of technology jobs to overseas workers since the trend began in the late 1990s. But with elections in both the United States and India, they believe 2004 could be a turning point.
“Politicians can’t outsource the vote,” said Scott Kirwin, founder of the Wilmington, Del., lobbying group Information Technology Professionals Association of America, which compiles data from nearly 100 antioutsourcing Web sites. Mr. Kirwin, who started the group after a large investment bank asked him to train the Indian worker who then replaced him, said only broad consumer revolt will reverse the trend.
“In the 1980s, many people boycotted companies that did business with the apartheid regime in South Africa,” he said. “Many of those same people have more money today and don’t like doing business with companies from countries that work against us politically, like France, or economically, like India and China. Consumer activism is an important part of putting the brakes on the outsourcing movement.”
Indian politicians and business leaders are worried their jobs could be in jeopardy. They have taken notice of the brewing backlash in the United States, where companies are replacing software developers with Indians who earn roughly one-sixth of what the U.S. workers command.
They are now promoting the economic benefits of migrating technology jobs to low-wage workers in the developing world.
Fear of a backlash was a major issue at a technology summit this month in Hyderabad, India. Indiana’s failed contract with Tata Consultancy Services, and customer complaints that prompted Dell Inc. to reroute some help desk calls from India to Idaho in November, worry Indians, who have received billions of dollars in outsourcing contracts.
“This is a matter of concern for all of us,” India’s info-tech minister, Arun Shourie, told officials from 30 Asian countries at the summit. “We must come together to find a consensus approach to fight this backlash.”
Business experts say India need not worry; Indiana and Dell are high-profile exceptions to what has become the rule of outsourcing.
In a report in mid-2003, Gartner Inc. predicted that at least one out of 10 technology jobs in the United States would move overseas by the end of 2004. Forrester Research predicts at least 3.3 million white-collar jobs and $136 billion in wages will shift from the United States to low-cost countries by 2015.
“The idea of a backlash makes for great press, and it makes for great rhetoric in an election year,” said John C. McCarthy, vice president of research at Forrester. “But the reality is that every day there’s a new customer with new cost savings from this. The economics are hugely compelling, and it’s not going away.”
View Entire StoryBy H. Leighton Steward
Fantasy replaces reality in Obama's green economy

By Chris Kahn - Associated Press
Gasoline prices have never been higher this time of the year. At $3.53 a gallon, ...

By Tom Howell Jr. - The Washington Times
A 29-year-old Moroccan man was arrested Friday on accusations he planned to detonate a suicide ...

By David Hill - The Washington Times
The House voted Friday night to approve Gov. Martin O’Malley’s same-sex marriage bill, sending the ...
Independent voices from the TWT Communities

A collection of Entertainment News and Reviews from Washington, D.C. to the beyond

Not your typical discussion, writer Conor Murphy writes about the cons, and pros, of politics

Children around the globe are too often silent. From victims of abuse - physical, mental, and sexual to those whose lives embrace joy, their stories are many and need to be heard.