Naysayers tight-lipped since success of Iraq vote

Skeptics of President Bush’s attempt to bring democracy to Iraq have been largely silent since Iraqis enthusiastically turned out for Sunday’s elections.

Billionaire Bush-basher George Soros and left-wing filmmaker Michael Moore were among critics of the administration’s Iraq policy who had no comment after millions of Iraqis went to the polls in their nation’s first free elections in decades.

The Carter Center determined that the security situation in Iraq was going to be too dangerous to send election monitors, so the Atlanta-based human rights organization founded by former President Jimmy Carter posted its personnel in neighboring Jordan.

Despite widespread predictions of spectacular terrorist attacks on election day in Iraq, fewer than 50 were killed, and the 60 percent turnout for the elections was much higher than many predicted.

Asked whether the Carter Center had a comment on the election, spokeswoman Kay Torrance said: “We wouldn’t have any ‘yea’ or ‘nay’ statement on Iraq.”

Mr. Carter told NBC’s “Today” show in September that he was confident the elections would not take place. “I personally do not believe they’re going to be ready for the election in January … because there’s no security there,” he said.

Mr. Soros, the Open Society Institute founder who contributed millions of dollars to groups seeking to prevent Mr. Bush’s re-election, had denounced as a “sham” the administration’s plans for a democratic Iraq.

“To claim that we are invading Iraq for the sake of establishing democracy is a sham, and the rest of the world sees it as such,” Mr. Soros said in a Washington speech in March 2003, adding that “the trouble goes much deeper.”

“It is not merely that the Bush administration’s policies may be wrong, it is that they are wrong,” Mr. Soros said in the speech. “Because we are unquestionably the most powerful, [the Bush administration claims] we have earned the right to impose our will on the rest of the world.”

Mr. Soros’ Web site (www.georgesoros.com) has no reference to the Iraqi elections. Its latest comments are in a Jan. 26 op-ed article on what Mr. Soros calls Mr. Bush’s “ambitious” second inaugural address.

“Mr. Soros has not released any statements about the elections in Iraq,” said Soros spokesman Michael Vachon. “He has been traveling since Sunday on various foundation projects and hasn’t had occasion to comment.”

Mr. Vachon said Mr. Soros’ “position regarding the Bush administration’s policies in Iraq and his criticism thereof have been consistent.”

In his Jan. 26 article, published in more than 20 newspapers, including the Toronto Globe and Mail, Mr. Soros said he agrees with Mr. Bush’s goal to spread democracy around the world, “and [I] have devoted the past 15 years and several billion dollars of my fortune to attaining it,” but accused the president of “Orwellian doublespeak.”

“Mr. Bush is right to assert that repressive regimes can no longer hide behind a cloak of sovereignty,” wrote Mr. Soros, 74, who made his fortune as an international currency trader. “But intervention in other states’ internal affairs must be legitimate.”

There has been no comment since the Iraq elections from Mr. Moore, the Academy Award-winning filmmaker who characterized the Iraqi insurgents as “Minutemen,” and predicted “they will win.”

Story Continues →