The Washington Times
  • Subscribe
  • Times News Services
  • RSS
  • Mobile Headlines
  • e-edition
  • E-MAIL ALERTS
  • REGISTER
  • LOG IN
  • E-MAIL ALERTS
  • WELCOME
  • Your Profile
  • Log Out
  • Front Page Image
  • Classifieds
  • Autos
  • Real Estate
  • Jobs
  • Special Sections
  • Customer Service
  • Home
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Sports
    • NFL
    • NBA/WNBA
    • MLB
    • NHL
    • Tennis
    • Golf
    • Motorsports
    • Soccer
    • NCAA
    • Olympics
    • Outdoors
    • Other
  • Culture
    • Home & Living
    • Family & Kids
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Travel
    • Health
    • Washington Visitors
    • Books
    • Military History
    • Life
    • Auto
    • TV Listings
    • Movie Listings
    • Death Notices
    • Entertainment
  • Themes
  • Communities
  • Marketplace
    • Autos
    • Jobs
    • Real Estate
    • Classifieds
    • Shopping
    • Dining Out
    • Education
    • TWT Store
  • Videos
    • Two Guys
    • Birnbaum on Washington
    • Liz Glover
    • Amanda Carpenter
    • Morning Briefing
    • Documentaries
    • Joe Giganti
    • Video Game Minute
  • Podcasts
    • About Headlines
    • Audio and Radio
    • America's Morning News
  • Politics

    Bill Clinton urges Dems to pass health bill

  • Security

    Obama: No religious faith justifies Fort Hood shootings

  • Local

    Gov. Kaine clears way for D.C. sniper's execution

  • Politics

    EXCLUSIVE: Warner: Obama misplayed health care debate

  • National

    Justices weigh juveniles' life without parole

  • National

    Leadership changes at The Times

  • National

    Hood suspect earlier came under FBI scrutiny

Tuesday, February 28, 2006

Courts could change ways to buy

Rate this story

Average 0.00
after 0 votes
Login or register to rate this story

  • Font Size -+
  • Print
  • Email
  • Comment
  • Tweet this!
  • Share
  • Article
  • Comments ()
  • Click-2-Listen
  • Videos

More Stories

  • Obama: No religious faith justifies Fort Hood shootings
  • Bill Clinton urges Dems to pass health bill
  • Obama to send more troops to Afghanistan
  • Hood suspect earlier came under FBI scrutiny

By

Wine has been sold in most of the United States through a legally mandated system of wholesale distribution for over 70 years. That system is now being challenged -- by consumers, producers and at least one powerful corporate interest.

Its defenders, themselves powerful and politically influential, are fighting back. When the dust settles, both how you shop for wine and which wines you can buy may well have changed.

Although the issues here certainly prove contentious, they are not especially complicated. At heart, the fight concerns a set of successful companies maintaining power or being compelled to give up power. All the other topics -- consumer rights, states' rights, protecting minors, collecting taxes and the like -- are tangential.

Trying to predict what will happen in this dispute is difficult. As Bob Dylan once sang, "the wheel's still in spin," so writers and critics shouldn't prophesy too much. Still, the intensity of the controversy, coupled with the fact that the disputants keep ending up in court, suggests that the status quo is unlikely to survive. Mr. Dylan's lyrics get to the heart of the matter. "The loser now," he wrote, "will be later to win / For the times they are a-changin'."

In order to understand what the hullabaloo is all about, begin with a little history. In 1933, when Prohibition ended, Congress gave the states, and, by extension, local municipalities, the authority to regulate the sale and distribution of alcohol.

Different states did different things. Some ran the booze business themselves, while others licensed private companies to do so. Some permitted wine sales in specialized liquor stores, while others allowed food markets to carry the product. Some states imposed high taxes as others levied no fees at all.

The result was what historian Thomas Pinney calls "a crazy, ramshackle structure of state and local regulations," a structure that "impeded, obstructed, and diverted" the flow of wine "in a thousand unpredictable and arbitrary ways." Although things have calmed down a bit during subsequent decades, wine availability is still affected.

Few states now monopolize the sale of alcohol. Pennsylvania remains the most prominent holdout. Consumers there still must buy wine from a store owned and run by the state, and, so, managed and staffed by state employees whose union politicians feel the need to court. Much the same is true in select local municipalities throughout the country, Montgomery County in Maryland being a prime example.

In other jurisdictions, however, local and state governments license (usually for a hefty fee) private entities to sell wine. They usually do so twice. First come establishments where consumers can buy wine -- retail stores, restaurants, bars and such. Second come the companies that can sell wine to those establishments. These are the wine (and liquor) wholesalers or distributors, and this licensing structure is what is often called the "three-tier system."

This system is what is now being challenged in courtrooms and legislatures throughout the country. The challenges come from three separate parties -- individual consumers, small wineries and, most recently, one powerful mega-retailer.

123Next »

Post a comment

There are comments on this article, submit your opinion!

Commenting is disabled for this entry.
If you feel there is still something worth mentioning about this entry please contact the author or the site admin.

Ask a Question

You Report

Do you have another point of view, photos, audio, video or more information about a story?

Top Stories

Most Read

  1. KELLNER: New Apple mouse really is 'Magic'
  2. EXCLUSIVE: Rare virus poses new threat to troops
  3. EXCLUSIVE: Warner: Obama misplayed health care debate
  4. Parents buying homes for kids at college
  5. EDITORIAL: Too scared to recognize terrorism
More Top Stories »
  1. PRUDEN: Fatal reluctance to see evil
  2. Deer dies after leap into D.C. zoo lion exhibit
  3. Federal Reserve opposed as big bank savior by odd allies
  4. Court refuses to halt sniper's execution
  5. Gov. Kaine clears way for D.C. sniper's execution

Most Shared

  1. PRUDEN: Fatal reluctance to see evil
  2. KELLNER: New Apple mouse really is 'Magic'
  3. Defense nominee won't reveal potential conflicts
  4. 'Fuzzy math' could drive health bill cost higher
  5. EDITORIAL: Too scared to recognize terrorism
More Top Stories »
  1. EXCLUSIVE: Rare virus poses new threat to troops
  2. Deer dies after leap into D.C. zoo lion exhibit
  3. Parents buying homes for kids at college
  4. The siren call of Shariah
  5. Sinking dollar fuels new gold rush

Most Commented

  1. PRUDEN: Fatal reluctance to see evil
  2. 'Fuzzy math' could drive health bill cost higher
  3. EDITORIAL: Too scared to recognize terrorism
  4. Defense nominee won't reveal potential conflicts
  5. Lieberman vows probe of Hood rampage
More Top Stories »
  1. Health bill faces roadblocks in Senate
  2. Jihadists in the military
  3. EDITORIAL: Mr. Obama, stay away from this wall
  4. 'Anti-vaccine' attitude hampers H1N1 effort
  5. Hood suspect earlier came under FBI scrutiny

Listen to Washington Times Radio

  • America's Morning News

    with John McCaslin and Melanie Morgan

Blogs & Columns

  • POTUS Notes

    New Dem talking point on Obama approval doesn't wash

  • The Back Story

    12 arrested at Pelosi's office

  • Belief Blog

    New Vatican constitution released

  • Out of Context

    Foods that might kill libido

  • Technology

    Facebook wins round against phishing spammer

  • On the Fly

    United lifts some 'award' blocking

  • Redskins 360

    Hall, Portis on radio

  • Tara's Two Cents

    On their way to summer vacation..

  • SNOBlog

    Beyond 'Woody'

Videos

Advertising Links
TWT Store
  • e-edition
  • Print Edition
  • Weekly Washington Times
TWT Affiliates
  • Middle East Times
  • Golf
  • UPI
  • Arbor Ballroom
  • Washington Times Global
  • About TWT
  • Press Room
  • F.A.Q.
  • Work for TWT
  • Advertise
  • Sponsors
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Site Map

All site contents © Copyright 2009 The Washington Times, LLC.