- Obama encourages ICE to stand down, say former border agents
- Pro-Palestinian protesters attack Israeli soccer team in Austria match
- Virginia police: 2 dead after storm at campground
- Ukrainian prime minister announces resignation
- House members question $17 billion VA request
- N.Y. Gov. Cuomo launches statewide task force to collect LGBT data
- Obama’s motorcade prevents woman in labor from crossing street to hospital
- Grijalva: Anti-trafficking law ‘line in the sand for many of us’
- Joe Biden: ‘Businesses are hiring at historic rates’
- Jeb Bush to Congress: Don’t use border crisis as excuse to delay immigration reform
MOVIE REVIEW: A pawn’s life
Question of the Day
Why would you make a movie about George W. Bush and exclude any serious discussion of Sept. 11?
By any reasonable measure, al Qaeda’s attack on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon was an era-defining event and easily the single most important moment of the Bush presidency. In cliche-speak, it’s the day that changed everything.
So why would Oliver Stone ignore it in “W.”? Perhaps because he doesn’t think the attacks changed anything at all.
The conspiracy-minded director’s latest film is an extension of the principle argument put forth in Mr. Stone’s other presidential pictures, “JFK” and “Nixon,” namely that the military-industrial complex, and not the president, runs things.
In Oliver Stone’s world, the CIA, the military and the FBI conspired to kill President Kennedy for pulling out of the Bay of Pigs and trying to end the Vietnam War before it really got started. In Oliver Stone’s world, President Nixon has little to no control over ending the Vietnam War because the machinery of combat has become self-perpetuating — an idea he can’t comprehend until a college student spells it out for him on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial.
In Oliver Stone’s “W.,” oilman Dick Cheney is committed to invading Iraq to steal its precious petroleum and to create an undefeatable military empire spanning the entirety of the Middle East and Central Asia. Sept. 11 didn’t prompt the invasion of Iraq and Afghanistan: Sept. 11 was merely the excuse for the invasion.
• See related:With ‘W.’ Stone jumps gun on history
Leaving aside questions of Mr. Stone’s lack of fidelity to the historical record, “W.” is a muddled movie with myriad structural problems, the most profound of which seems to have been deciding where it should end. This is unsurprising, I suppose, since the Bush presidency — and the Iraq war with which it is so preoccupied — are both still unfolding.
Mr. Stone also tries to recycle a trick he utilized to great effect in “Nixon.” There are constant flashbacks to Mr. Bush’s formative years intended to examine his psychological hangups. The result in “W.” is confused, however; this is a movie that clearly could have used an extra month or two in the editing bay.
The performances resemble impersonations from mediocre “Saturday Night Live” skits. The likenesses are there, and some of the actors sound like their real-life counterparts (others don’t even try), but there’s little insight into their motivations. One notable exception is Jeffrey Wright, who does an excellent job of portraying Colin Powell’s inner conflict during the lead-up to the Iraq War: He played the good soldier in public despite his doubts about international support for a pre-emptive war and the lack of a clear exit strategy.
In the end, I’m unsure who “W.” will really appeal to: It’s a poor historical document; it’s not nasty enough for people who hate Bush and too nasty for the few still supporting him; and its visual blandness and structural problems preclude it from being considered a legitimate work of art.
RATING: PG-13 (language including sexual references, some alcohol abuse, smoking and brief disturbing war images)
CREDITS: Directed by Oliver Stone
About the Author
- BEYOND HOLLYWOOD: Poking fun at blaxploitation
- MOVIES/BUNCH: A year of hits... and misses (mostly hits)
- 'Avatar' rising
- Blu-ray for everyone
- MOVIE REVIEW: 'Did You Hear About the Morgans?'
Latest Blog Entries
The subsidies are a hit with patients who don't exist
- Hamas rejects Kerry's call for cease-fire; Fears grow others could join fight against Israel
- Obama's empty tough-talk: Gun prosecutions plummet on his watch
- Algerian plane diverted due to storms, second aircraft: 116 missing
- Whistleblowers flood VA with lawsuits despite apology
- 'We're coming for you, Barack Obama': Top U.S. official discloses threat from ISIL terrorists
- Obama says public not familiar enough with issues
- Obama dispatches researchers to border to check on National Guard
- NAPOLITANO: What if our democracy is a fraud?
- Astronaut shares 'saddest photo' from space: Bombs bursting over Israel, Gaza
- Conservative groups decry Democrats' 'war on women' tactic
Obama's biggest White House 'fails'
Celebrities turned politicians
Athletes turned actors
20 gadgets that changed the world
Fighting in Iraq