Tom Knott: A fresh quarterback won’t solve stale issues

Question of the Day

Is it still considered bad form to talk politics during a social gathering?

View results

Of all the issues afflicting the Redskins, starting with the “fresh set of eyes,” quarterback Jason Campbell is the least of them.

This is not intended to be an endorsement of Campbell. We just do not know with him.

And, really, how can anyone know, given the limitations around him?

He is standing behind a beat-up, third-rate offensive line. His wide receivers are either on the downside of their careers or second-tier types. His running game is mostly nonexistent because of, again, a decrepit offensive line and an aging Clinton Portis.

Incidentally, there was no better evidence of the latter than on his 78-yard run midway through the third quarter, when he had only one defender to beat but had neither the extra gear nor finesse to juke the person.

So Portis was dragged down at the Kansas City 10 - no way that would have happened two or three years ago - and another wonderful red-zone opportunity resulted in a field goal.

Yet problems in the red zone are inevitable if the defense has to respect only the Campbell-to-Chris Cooley connection. It certainly does not have to respect the running game or the play-action pass of the Redskins.

And that segues back to Campbell. He has no game-breaking weapons at his disposal. How would Brett Favre be coping in this offense? Peyton Manning? Tom Brady? Not that Campbell is doing anything that prompts comparisons to those future Hall of Fame quarterbacks.

It is just that his is a can’t-win situation. He has been put in a position to fail.

That became abundantly clear after Jim Zorn replaced Campbell at halftime with Todd Collins, and it was anemic business as usual.

With all these obvious drawbacks, the brain trust of the Redskins has promoted the “fresh set of eyes” to the “fresh play caller” on offense. The “fresh set of eyes” has been with the team for about a cup of coffee, so the move makes perfect sense in the dysfunctional football world of Dan Snyder and Vinny Cerrato.

If there is one thing that is always consistent with the Redskins, it is their dysfunction.

Perhaps the “fresh set of eyes” will unearth a gem or two in the scaled-down playbook of the Redskins. That is another thing with the Redskins. The Redskins are unable to go very deep into their playbook, what with the offensive linemen often giving Campbell a two count of protection before going, “Look out.”

That means quick out passes, quick passes over the middle, screen plays and dump passes.

That means Campbell is rarely able to utilize one of his greatest strengths, which is a strong passing arm.

Story Continues →

View Entire Story
blog comments powered by Disqus