- Deportations come mostly from border, DHS chief says
- NATO sends surveillance planes to watch Ukraine
- Climate change not a top concern of Americans, poll shows
- GM faces federal investigation for slow recall that led to 13 deaths
- Iran president reaches out to Oman on friendship tour
- FAA’s pre-Malaysia flight warning: 777s have cracking, corrosion issues
- Facebook HQ locked down; employees searched as police field threat
- Glenn Ford free, after serving 30 years for murder he didn’t commit
- Congressman: McAuliffe victory means gun control a winning message
- Clinton aide admits soliciting disgraced D.C. fundraiser; says actions were legal
Appeals court hears Calif. gay-marriage case
SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — The fight over California’s same-sex marriage ban reached the next legal level Monday when it went before a federal appeals court during a nationally televised hearing in San Francisco.
The proceedings before a three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals began with arguments about whether sponsors of voter-approved Proposition 8 had legal standing to challenge a lower court’s ruling that the ban was unconstitutional.
Later, lawyers were expected to argue about the constitutionality of the measure.
The court announced Nov. 17 that it had granted C-SPAN permission to televise live the federal proceedings on the case for the first time.
It’s not unusual for the 9th Circuit Court to allow the televising of such hearings. It recently allowed a hearing on Arizona’s controversial immigration law to be aired.
The issue of whether sponsors have legal standing in the case surfaced after outgoing California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and Attorney General Jerry Brown both refused to challenge the ruling that overturned the ban. Mr. Schwarzenegger and Mr. Brown would have been responsible for enforcing the ban.
Attorney Charles Cooper, who represents the sponsors of Proposition 8, said they should be allowed to appeal because of the moves by Mr. Brown and Mr. Schwarzenegger. However, his claim met skepticism by Judge N. Randy Smith.
“There is no question the attorney general has a duty to defend all the causes the state or any state official is a party in,” Judge Smith said. “Did you ever seek an injunction or an order or anything suggesting the attorney general should appeal and appeal?”
The panel of judges also grilled a lawyer representing Imperial County, which has sought to defend Proposition 8 if the appeals court determines the measure’s backers do not have standing.
Judge Michael Hawkins repeatedly asked attorney Robert Tyler why his primary client was a deputy county clerk, not the elected clerk herself.
“It is a question that concerns some of us here on the panel,” Judge Hawkins said. “We wonder why there is not a single sentence in (the deputy’s) affadavit saying she is acting on behalf of the clerk.”
The judges also questioned whether the lower court’s ruling that overturned Proposition 8 would apply statewide or only to the two counties where the pair of same-sex couples who sued to overturn the measure unsuccessfully sought marriage licenses.
Opponents of Proposition 8 contend it violates the due process and equal protection rights of gays and lesbians under the U.S. Constitution by denying them the right to marry the person of their choice and by singling them out for disparate treatment without a legitimate rationale.
Proposition 8’s sponsors also maintain that U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker ignored U.S. Supreme Court precedents holding that the U.S. Constitution does not guarantee gays the right to wed.
TWT Video Picks
An America drowning in red ink is the land of the free no more
- Inside the Beltway: A new interest in Rahm Emanuel for 2016?
- HURT: John Kerry The ridiculous face of a ridiculous U.S. diplomacy
- David Jolly wins in Florida, GOP keeps swing district seat
- Brennan: Russia 'absolutely' could invade eastern Ukraine
- Kim Jong-un calls for execution of 33 Christians
- Joel Osteen church victimized in $600K theft
- U.S. pilot scares off Iranians with 'Top Gun'-worthy stunt: 'You really ought to go home'
- Search for missing Malaysian airliner widens as mystery deepens
- Bill Clinton poses for photo with Bunny Ranch prostitutes
- Obamacare 3 million shy of target with 19 days left to sign up
Pope Francis meets his 'mini-me'
Celebrity deaths in 2014
Winter storm hits states — again