The first time Elena Kagan appeared before the Senate Judiciary Committee, she deftly deflected the initial Republican attack she faced on her way to a smooth confirmation as the Obama administration’s solicitor general.
And while Ms. Kagan’s confirmation is all but assured, this week’s hearings will give the American public another chance to see how she handles what is expected to be withering Republican opposition.
President Obama nominated Ms. Kagan, 50, in May to replace Justice John Paul Stevens, who is retiring after 35 years on the bench. If confirmed, she will join Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Sonia Sotomayor, Mr. Obama’s first appointment, on the bench — the first time three female justices will have served together on the high court.
Last year, during Ms. Kagan’s nomination hearings for solicitor general, the first Republican attack she faced came from Sen. Arlen Specter of Pennsylvania, who was the top Republican on the committee at the time.
Mr. Specter, who has since changes parties, grilled her about a memo she wrote as a clerk for Justice Thurgood Marshall some 20 years earlier. The memo questioned whether religious organizations should be allowed to receive federal funding to deal with issues surrounding teen pregnancy, and Ms. Kagan quickly thanked Mr. Specter for bringing it up.
“I first looked at that memo, thought about that memo, for the first time in 20 years, I suppose, just a couple of days ago when it was included on a blog post,” Ms. Kagan said. “And I looked at it and I thought, ‘That is the dumbest thing I have ever heard.’”
As laughter filled the hearing room, Mr. Specter replied: “You do not have to go any further.” Her ease in handling the senator’s question set the tone for the rest of the hearing, which ended uneventfully and with her easy confirmation as solicitor general.
It is unlikely Republicans will be as easily deterred again, but the GOP is hamstrung somewhat by Ms. Kagan’s lack of a judicial record. She stands to become the first justice to ascend to the Supreme Court in 40 years who has not previously served as a judge.
During the Sunday television talk shows, several leading Republican senators questioned whether Ms. Kagan could be an impartial judge while Democrats praised her record and predicted easy confirmation.
Sen. Jeff Sessions of Alabama, the Judiciary Committee’s ranking Republican, said the nominee has “real problems” she will have to address, including whether she is “committed to the rule of law even if she may not like the law.”
Mr. Sessions also asked whether her lack of judicial experience meant she would put more focus on her political views.
Sen. John Cornyn, Texas Republican, said the hearings could be as much about Mr. Obama as Ms. Kagan, adding the president was “trying to get somebody through who has a very sparse record and who he believes will be a reliable vote on the left wing of the United States Supreme Court.”
Committee Chairman Sen. Patrick J. Leahy, Vermont Democrat, said the hearing would showcase Ms. Kagan as “a brilliant woman, a brilliant legal mind.”
Before becoming solicitor general, Ms. Kagan was the dean of the Harvard Law School. And it was an incident during her time at Harvard that has so far provided the most fodder for Republicans.View Entire Story
© Copyright 2013 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.
Ben Conery is a member of the investigative team covering the Supreme Court and legal affairs. Prior to coming to The Washington Times in 2008, Mr. Conery covered criminal justice and legal affairs for daily newspapers in Connecticut and Massachusetts. He was a 2006 recipient of the New England Newspaper Association’s Publick Occurrences Award for a series of articles about ...
'Your papers, please' must never be heard in America
Independent voices from the TWT Communities
Sometimes life requires a paradigm twist.
We all eat, and food should be fun and healthful. Food Commune celebrates the food we eat, the people we eat with and the spirits we enjoy.
First over-the-counter column approved for fast and effective relief from even your worst media-induced headache.
Benghazi: The anatomy of a scandal
Vietnam Memorial adds four names
Cinco de Mayo on the Mall