- Obama not worried about Ebola at upcoming African summit in D.C.
- Obama: ‘We tortured some folks’ after 9/11
- Obama administration asked whole D.C. Circuit to take on major Obamacare case
- Mark Levin: Topple GOP leadership or country will ‘unravel’
- Massachusetts to let police chief deny gun buys to those deemed unfit
- John Kerry condemns attack on Israeli soldiers, kidnapping
- U.S. starts to evacuate American Ebola patients from West Africa: Report
- Geraldo slammed as ‘dummy’ for backing Clinton’s bin Laden claim
- Israeli spokesman: No need to debate who broke the cease-fire
- 35 Palestinians killed; Israeli officer missing
High court debates overpopulation in California prisons
Safety, inmates’ rights at issue
Question of the Day
The Supreme Court heard arguments Tuesday in a case about prison overcrowding in California that pitted public safety worries against the constitutional rights of the state’s inmates.
Along with those two competing interests, the case also hinged largely on how much time the state should have to solve problems that have plagued its prison system for decades.
California is appealing to the high court a 2009 order from a lower court that the state reduce its prison population within two years. The lower court said overcrowding is the primary cause of prison conditions that violate constitutional prohibitions against cruel and unusual punishment.
Carter G. Phillips, a Washington lawyer representing the state, called the order “extraordinarily premature.” He told the justices the order does not give the state enough time to complete ongoing measures that will reduce inmate population without a mass release of prisoners.
“The reality is that anytime you say you are going to release 30,000 inmates in a very compressed period of time, I guarantee you that there is going to be more crime and people are going to die on the streets of California,” Mr. Phillips said. “There is no way out of that particular box.”
Justice Breyer called the conditions “horrendous.”
Mr. Phillips was not specific about how much time the state needed, but said in response to questioning from the justices that five years could be enough.
Donald Specter, a lawyer for the inmates, argued the state has already been given enough time.
“The constitutional violations have been ongoing for 20 years,” Mr. Specter said. “We are dealing here with cases of life and death and serious injury.”
The lower court said prison overcrowding led to inmates being denied their constitutional rights to adequate medical and mental health care. According to court documents, about one inmate dies every eight days because of a lack of basic medical care. At the time of the ruling, California had 165,000 inmates, the most of any state, and its 33 prisons were at roughly twice their designed capacity. The lower court ordered the state to reduce its inmate population to 137.5 percent of design capacity - a reduction of as many as 46,000 inmates.
Mr. Phillips argued that the inmate population has already been reduced to 147,000. The system was designed to hold 80,000 prisoners.
Mr. Phillips said the reduction came from increases in “good time” credits for some inmates; Mr. Specter said most of the reduction is from transferring inmates to prisons in other states.
© Copyright 2014 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.
About the Author
Ben Conery is a member of the investigative team covering the Supreme Court and legal affairs. Prior to coming to The Washington Times in 2008, Mr. Conery covered criminal justice and legal affairs for daily newspapers in Connecticut and Massachusetts. He was a 2006 recipient of the New England Newspaper Association’s Publick Occurrences Award for a series of articles about ...
TWT Video Picks
By Orrin G. Hatch
Procedural changes impede the chamber's traditional deliberative function
- U.N. condemns Israel, U.S. for not sharing Iron Dome with Hamas
- Border agents cleared of civil rights complaints from illegal immigrant children
- Porn-surfing feds blame boredom, lack of work for misbehavior
- Obama military strategy too weak for future security, panel reports
- 'Big Bang' star Mayim Bialik helps send bulletproof vests to IDF
- Ben Carson takes major step toward presidential campaign
- Pentagon wants extra $19M to equip, train Ukrainian troops
- Ted Nugent slams 'lying freaks' at liberal media: I'm 'doing God's work'
- Houston mayor: Sorry that police put man's blind dog on road to die
- HUSAIN: Worlds grand ayatollahs rally behind Sistani
Top 10 U.S. military helicopters
Obama's biggest White House 'fails'
Celebrities turned politicians
Athletes turned actors