Emotions run high in “Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close,” one of the boldest cinematic tacklings of Sept. 11 yet. It’s a project fraught with obvious peril, with pitfalls of sentimentality, exploitation or, simply, audience reluctance. The source material, Jonathan Safran Foer’s 2005 book, is far from normal Hollywood stuff. One of the first novels to take up the tragedy, it’s inherently literary and experimental in its fractured storytelling, occasionally drifting by with just a few words on a page.
But the film, directed by Stephen Daldry (“The Hours,” “The Reader”), has opted to go for the jugular: to dive straight into grief and loss; to face the stark images of that day; and, it is hoped, to emerge on the other side with healing and release.
“Some people might find the wound too big and that they can’t go there - and they shouldn’t go there,” Mr. Daldry said. “Some people will find it cathartic. I had to follow my own instincts on it.”
“Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close” is about an uncommonly bright 11-year-old boy, possibly with Asperger’s syndrome, named Oskar (Thomas Horn). A year after losing his father (Tom Hanks) on what he only calls “the worst day,” Oskar tries to keep his memory of his father alive by searching across New York City for the lock that fits a mysterious key. His mother (Sandra Bullock) is seemingly left out of his search, but joining him is his grandmother’s tenant and very possibly his grandfather (Max von Sydow), a speechless and mysterious old man.
Oskar’s journey leads him irrevocably back to “the worst day,” which, in flashbacks, is seen in the minute detail of everyday life, in heartbreaking phone calls from his father and in the most searing visuals. Depicted is the full panorama of the smoking towers in a perfect blue sky, and, in nightmare recollection, people plummeting to the ground.
“There was a big discussion in my own head about, ‘Do I really want to see the Twin Towers at all?’ ” Mr. Daldry said. “There was a choice about, ‘Do I want to see what happened to Tom Hanks?’ I went, ‘I literally cannot do that.’ The idea of building an office, the Windows of the World - I just couldn’t do it.”
Making the film - which Mr. Daldry can only summarize as “a challenging emotional experience” - has clearly left a mark on the British director and those who worked on it. Recalling a recent advance screening, during which a survivor from the South Tower stood up and spoke afterward, Mr. Daldry cuts off and breaks for a smoke. There have been many rich, story-filled meetings already with children of parents killed on 9/11, with firefighters and with people who lost a loved one.
The film is still fresh for Mr. Daldry. The seven-month production ended earlier this year, but just 10 days before a recent interview, he was still shooting - a small addition to make a scene in the Far Rockaways of Queens more understandable.
“I hope people are ready for it,” Miss Bullock said, welling up at times. “The movie-going experience of this with everyone in the room is therapy. And I hate the word ‘therapy,’ but it’s healing. It is the collective supporting each other in whatever they’re grieving.”
The film is making a late push toward audiences. Long viewed as an Oscar contender, the movie was kept under wraps by Mr. Rudin (“The Social Network”) until very late in the year. It’s an exceptionally heart-wrenching film, likely to be among the weepiest experiences at the movies in years and, therefore, likely to engender either ardent support or skeptical derision. Certainly, that the cast includes two of America’s most beloved stars - Mr. Hanks and Miss Bullock - should make the film more palatable.
Both audiences and filmmakers have shown reluctance for Sept. 11 stories. More than 10 years later, it’s possible they’re ready for a more ambitious engagement with the tragedy, after earlier mainstream movies such as “United 93” and “World Trade Center.” This year also saw the long-delayed release of Kenneth Lonergan’s post-9/11 “Margaret.”
“Obviously, the subject matter is certainly what it’s about to some extent,” said screenwriter Eric Roth (“Forrest Gump,” “The Insider”). “But I think ‘Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close’ is about something else. I think it’s more about grief.”
Mr. Roth said Mr. Foer was “nothing but a prince” about the adaptation, and that he helped with some aspects of the script, including the voice-overs. The film does away with a past story line that runs through the novel.
Casting Oskar, the film’s protagonist, was one of the biggest challenges for the filmmakers. Thirteen-year-old Thomas, a newcomer to acting, was discovered after he was seen winning a kids’ episode of “Jeopardy!” But his performance has drawn raves. In a recent interview with his father alongside, Thomas was as sharp and as articulate as Oskar.View Entire Story
By Douglas Holtz-Eakin
The young drop coverage to avoid higher premiums
Independent voices from the TWT Communities
We welcome you to the intimate and personal thoughts on the news and events we, as editors, watch, read, and discuss with our writers every day.
Consummate traveler Todd DeFeo explores the unique stories that make destinations worth going to.
Looking at pop culture, politics and social issues.
Political commentary and literary criticism in an era of eroding liberty
Benghazi: The anatomy of a scandal
Vietnam Memorial adds four names
Cinco de Mayo on the Mall
NRA kicks off annual convention
California wildfires wreak havoc