- Hacking software could put ‘zombie drone army’ in user’s hands
- Support for stricter gun laws drops: poll
- 10 whales dead, 41 others stranded in Everglades
- John Boehner faces bipartisan pressure to allow gay-rights vote
- Martin Bashir resigns from MSNBC over ‘ill-judged’ comments about Sarah Palin
- Rep. Duncan Hunter: While Obama prays for Iranian change, U.S. should ready its nukes
- Best company ever? Veteran Beer Co. exists to employ vets, provide quality beer
- Iran official: Sanctions ‘utterly failed’ to stop nuclear program
- ‘Black Santa’ display at IU sparks student outrage
- Joint Chiefs chair Dempsey: Pentagon, VA too slow in merging medical systems
FDA device regulator faces critics from both sides
Question of the Day
WASHINGTON (AP) - The Food and Drug Administration is approving medical devices too slowly. Or too quickly _ depending on whom you ask.
House lawmakers heard both arguments Thursday at a hearing examining the FDA’s regulation of U.S. medical devices, a $120-billion industry that includes everything from hospital beds to heart pumps.
FDA leadership are in the process of overhauling the 35-year old system used to clear most devices, triggering a slew of reports and analyses aimed at influencing the agency’s plans.
On the one side are device manufacturers, who charge that FDA reviews have gotten longer and less predictable, forcing some companies to launch their devices overseas to stay in business. They say American patients no longer have access to the latest medical treatments, forcing some to fly to Europe for surgery.
But consumer safety advocates say just the opposite: FDA is clearing too many devices, too quickly, jeopardizing patient safety.
Can they both be right?
Shuren said the U.S. system is not inherently slower than Europe’s, though it does require an extra level of evidence. European regulators require that a device be safe and perform as described on its label. The FDA has those standards but also requires that the device be proven to successfully treat a disease. Shuren points to a handful of devices that were rejected by the FDA and approved in Europe, only to later be recalled for safety reasons.
“Just because a technology is available in another country doesn’t mean it works, or even that it’s necessarily safe,” he said.
The main problem the FDA has encountered in recent years, according to Shuren, is the declining quality of applications from device makers. According to Shuren, more than 50 percent of applications for conventional medical devices are missing key information, leading to delays that should have been avoided.
“We’re stepping up to the plate to do our part to get this right. But if it’s going to work we need industry to do their part,” Shuren told members of the House Energy and Commerce Committee’s Health Subcommittee.
“Investment is drying up, companies are moving overseas or closing their doors and U.S. patients are being denied timely access to safe and effective new medical products,” said Dr. Josh Makower, a medical device inventor and consulting professor at Stanford University.
Makower and the others pointed out that venture capital, which is critical to start-up companies, has dropped 37 percent across the device sector since 2007. While some of that decline is unquestionably due to the recession, entrepreneurs insist the FDA’s regulatory stance is also to blame.
Makower hammered home a key argument of device companies: that it typically takes companies two years longer to get devices approved in the U.S. than in Europe.
By Tom Harris and Madhav Khandekar
Bad science puts rich nations on the hook for trillions in climate liabilities
- Hola: Boehner prepares to push amnesty bill through House
- Puerto Rico caravan honoring Paul Walker ends in 6 drunken-driving arrests, 72 speeding tickets
- First Dog Sunny knocks down Ashtyn Gardner; Michelle Obama yanks leash
- Martin Bashir resigns from MSNBC over 'ill-judged' comments about Sarah Palin
- EDITORIAL: Motor City meltdown
- Apple wins facial recognition patent for iPhone 6
- HURT: Postal Service misses address by a whole continent
- Allen West warns Obamas backdoor gun control is moving forward
- U.S. drops 2,000 mice on Guam by parachute to kill snakes
- Issa: FBI impeding inquiry into IRS targeting of conservative groups
Independent voices from the The Washington Times Communities
Wall Street news for retail investors who want to know what's going on.
Does it take over 25 years in public service to really know what goes on in Washington?
Despite cynicism about the law, it can provide you justice, protection, and ensure your rights.
All of the world’s problems, solved on your back porch