- ‘Tis the Season: London florist creates $4.6 million Christmas wreath
- No tailgating allowed at Super Bowl XLVIII
- Pentagon to transport African troops to Central African Republic
- Chinese man fed up with his girlfriend’s shopping jumps to his death
- Ukraine leader to talk with protesters; Washington urges caution
- Pope Francis: A nun saved my life
- Israeli P.M. Netanyahu backs out of Mandela funeral
- Elian Gonzalez makes first trip outside Cuba since custody battle
- U.S., British intelligence agents enter online sci-fi world to spy on gamers
- Sarah Palin to host the outdoors show ‘Amazing America’
Scientific exchanges with China broke law
Obama administration officials broke the law by holding science and technology exchanges with Beijing contrary to legislation banning such cooperation, members of Congress and congressional auditors said Wednesday.
John Holdren, director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) "defied the legislation," Rep. Frank R. Wolf, Virginia Republican and sponsor of the law, told a hearing of the House Foreign Affairs subcommittee on oversight and investigations.
Both OSTP and the National Aeronautics and Space Administration were named in a section that Mr. Wolf added to the omnibus appropriations act passed by Congress in April to fund the government.
The section blocked the agencies from spending any money on bilateral meetings or exchanges that boost science and technology cooperation with Beijing or Chinese companies.
"OSTP violated [the] provision," said Thomas H. Armstrong, a lawyer from the Government Accountability Office, Congress' investigation and audit arm.
Mr. Holdren said at the hearing that he sought legal guidance from the Department of Justice "because of the importance of OSTP's role in diplomatic relations with China" and the "value to the country" of the exchanges and visits the agency was conducting.
The Justice advice was "very clear in its language that the section was unconstitutional" and that his agency could continue to go about its bilateral business "as agents designated by the president for the conduct of diplomatic relations with China" - who were not subject to the legislative branch - Mr. Holdren said.
"Their opinion is binding on me," Mr. Holdren said of the Justice Department lawyers. "It represents the view of the administration."
The GAO's Mr. Armstrong said the law was passed by both chambers of Congress and signed by the president - without any accompanying statement that successive administrations have used to indicate reservations about aspects of legislation.
That meant the law was "entitled to a heavy presumption in favor of constitutionality," he said, and, "absent a judicial opinion from a federal court of jurisdiction," ought to be enforced.
He noted, however, that enforcement would be a job for the Justice Department.
Subcommittee Chairman Rep. Dana Rohrabacher, California Republican, said there was a "major constitutional issue to be resolved," about the extent to which Congress could use the purse strings to dictate policy, especially in the arena of foreign affairs where courts and lawmakers traditionally have given a great deal of deference to the executive branch.
Mr. Rohrabacher criticized the administration's policy on science and technology cooperation with China.
"Any efforts on our part to reach out to the Chinese communists, to engage them on matters of technology is, quite frankly, not just naive, it is dangerous," Mr. Rohrabacher said.
"When personnel from either of these organizations travel to the People's Republic of China, collaborate on projects, share data, or attend conferences ... it is a serious national security problem."
He cited a history of Chinese efforts to steal U.S. technology
Mr. Holdren and NASA chief Charles Bolden Jr. defended the administration's record, saying the benefits of technological and scientific collaboration with China outweighed the risks.
"We have guarded our nation's secrets," Mr. Bolden said.
Cooperation with China is "clearly in the U.S. interest," argued the ranking member of the subcommittee, Rep. Russ Carnahan, Missouri Democrat.
At such a "critical time for the nation's space exploration plans," Mr. Bolden added, "having the flexibility to enter into these partnerships [with other countries, including China] has been key" to U.S. leadership in space.
Bipartisan support for cooperation with China "has spanned many administrations," he said.
"I believe that some level of cooperation with China ... can be ... in the best interests of both nations," he said.
Such cooperation also "strengthens our hand in getting China to change those aspects of its conduct that we oppose," said Mr. Holdren, citing human rights and economic issues.
He said the Innovation Dialogue with Beijing - one of the initiatives under fire - had helped "roll back aspects of Chinese innovation policy that discriminated against American businesses."
"American businesses are very grateful," Mr. Holdren said.
He added that cooperation on disease and other biological reporting issues had "enhanced our capability to deal with infectious diseases" and invasive pests originating in China.
© Copyright 2013 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.
About the Author
By Tom Fitton
- Chinese man fed up with his girlfriend's shopping jumps to his death
- CURL: Obama tells a whopper on IRS scandal
- MILLER: Brady Campaign says Colorado recalls due to NRA, not grassroots opposition to gun control
- WOLF: The president's other Obamacare lies
- Lawmakers see 'false narrative' of Obama as a terrorist fighter
- Ted Cruz sees legal landmines ahead for Obamacare
- Obama lied about Syrian chemical attack, 'cherry-picked' intelligence: report
- MSNBC host: Obamacare a 'wealthy white men' racist word
- Satanists petition for statue at Oklahoma Statehouse
- Bill OReilly reminds: Nelson Mandela was a communist
Independent voices from the The Washington Times Communities
Richard Ivory, editor-in-chief of Hip Hop Republicans and HHR at Communities Digital News, turns his interests, and pen, to the people making news today.
Find the latest news and happening that effect those in the Washington D.C., Northern Virginia and Maryland Metro region.
The world impacts us. What happens in our towns, cities, states, country and on this planet makes a difference to us.
Happiness is attainable. Morning to night. I love to teach, deal with folks that have an issue and really wish to tackle it and write.
White House pets gone wild!
Let it snow