Butz will star opposite “Twilight” star Elizabeth Reaser in a Second Stage Theatre revival. He won a best actor Tony Award this summer playing a frumpy FBI agent hot on the heels of a con man in “Catch Me If You Can.”
The play begins previews on Jan. 24 and officially opens on Feb. 13.
Butz also won a Tony in 2005 for “Dirty Rotten Scoundrels.”
Vogel’s play about the strained relationship between a young woman and her aunt’s husband is returning to New York City for the first time since its world premiere 15 years ago.