- Obama not worried about Ebola at upcoming African summit in D.C.
- Obama: ‘We tortured some folks’ after 9/11
- Obama administration asked whole D.C. Circuit to take on major Obamacare case
- Mark Levin: Topple GOP leadership or country will ‘unravel’
- Massachusetts to let police chief deny gun buys to those deemed unfit
- John Kerry condemns attack on Israeli soldiers, kidnapping
- U.S. starts to evacuate American Ebola patients from West Africa: Report
- Geraldo slammed as ‘dummy’ for backing Clinton’s bin Laden claim
- Israeli spokesman: No need to debate who broke the cease-fire
- 35 Palestinians killed; Israeli officer missing
MOVIE REVIEW: ‘In Darkness’
A poignant piece of ‘defeated art’
Question of the Day
I’m of two minds about “In Darkness,” a film about a Polish sewer worker who shelters a group of Jews from the Lvov ghetto during the last days of the Nazi occupation in 1943. Based on a 1991 nonfiction book by Robert Marshall, the film — an Oscar nominee for best foreign film — places its emphasis on a sliver of feel-good anecdote that threatens to diminish the larger history it taps.
It’s a moving story, made more poignant by the transformation of its protagonist Leopold Socha (Robert Wieckiewicz) from anti-Semitic con man to selfless humanitarian. Yet it’s exactly the sort of movie anticipated (and dreaded) by Elie Wiesel in his moving 1989 essay, “Art and the Holocaust: Trivializing Memory.” The Holocaust, Mr. Wiesel wrote, “defeated art, because just as no one could imagine Auschwitz before Auschwitz, no one can now retell Auschwitz after Auschwitz.”
While “In Darkness” isn’t literally about Auschwitz, it is an effort to locate a grain of heroism amid the most catastrophic failure of moral courage in human history. The camera cannot convey the unspeakable reality of the Holocaust, and even if it could, such a film would not make a fit subject for commercial cinema. Instead, we get films like “Schindler’s List” and “Life Is Beautiful,” which, with noble intent, mix kitsch with horrific imagery. The result invariably softens and sentimentalizes the subject matter for human consumption. “In Darkness” is squarely in this camp.
The film has other flaws. For one thing, the civilian population is depicted largely as callous but non-acting bystanders to the depredations visited on the Jews of the Lvov ghetto. Instead, Ukrainian troops backing the Nazis are depicted as some of the worst and most ruthless hunters of Jews. It is one of these, a Ukrainian officer named Bortnik (Michal Zurawski), who knows Socha and promises him bounties for recovering any Jews that might be hiding in the Lvov sewers.
It’s this bargain that sets up Socha for the conflict that has him teetering between villainy and heroism. His original plan is to bilk the Jews, led by the charismatic Mundek Margulies (Benno Furmann), for weekly payments until their money runs out. Once that happens, he intends to sell them to the Ukrainians. But along the way, Socha begins to identify with the terrorized, dehumanized Jews, and despite his reflexive anti-Semitism, begins to actively thwart the Nazi occupation and its agents.
“In Darkness” may be kitsch, and it may indulge in a bit of historical score settling, but it is also an impressive piece of filmmaking. The scenes set in the sewers are genuinely claustrophobic. The naturalistic acting style of the European stars is well-suited to the film, and there is a great deal of complexity in the relations between the Jews who manage to buy their way into Socha’s care.
Mr. Wiesel’s point, that “the Holocaust is not a subject like all the others,” is well-taken. On balance, “In Darkness” is a moving tribute to an unsung hero, despite the movie’s melodramatic leanings.
TITLE: “In Darkness”
CREDITS: Directed by Agnieszka Holland; written by David F. Shamoon, based on the book by Robert Marshall
RATING: R for violence, sexuality and scenes of depravity
RUNNING TIME: 145 minutes; in Polish, German, Yiddish and Ukrainian with English subtitles
MAXIMUM RATING: FOUR STARS
TWT Video Picks
By Orrin G. Hatch
Procedural changes impede the chamber's traditional deliberative function
- Border agents cleared of civil rights complaints from illegal immigrant children
- U.N. condemns Israel, U.S. for not sharing Iron Dome with Hamas
- Ben Carson takes major step toward presidential campaign
- Obama military strategy too weak for future security, panel reports
- Porn-surfing feds blame boredom, lack of work for misbehavior
- Feds raid S.C. home to seize Land Rover in EPA emission-control crackdown
- CRUZ: A tale of two hospitals: One in Israel, one in Gaza
- Pentagon wants extra $19M to equip, train Ukrainian troops
- Ted Nugent slams 'lying freaks' at liberal media: I'm 'doing God's work'
- Houston mayor: Sorry that police put man's blind dog on road to die
Top 10 U.S. military helicopters
Obama's biggest White House 'fails'
Celebrities turned politicians
Athletes turned actors