- Arkansas voter ID law struck down by state judge
- FDA proposes ban on e-cigarette sales to minors
- Bad omen? Italian man crushed to death by John Paul II crucifix
- Company stopped from accepting abortion waste
- Girl surprises Michelle Obama with unemployed dad’s resume
- ‘Harry Potter’ religion class seeks to enlighten students on ‘God, sin, and theodicy’
- ‘Optionally piloted’ Black Hawk helicopter clears tests; future missions to go ‘fully unmanned’
- Vice News reporter kidnapped in Ukraine is freed after being beaten, blindfolded
- FCC’s new ‘net neutrality’ proposal sparks outrage among consumer advocates
- Families of ferry’s lost confront South Korean officials
Court revives gay-marriage suit
Decision comes as effort to change state constitution heats up
A ruling released Monday by a three-judge appellate panel in Minnesota has revived a gay-marriage lawsuit just as the battle over a state marriage amendment is getting underway.
The decision was a victory for gay-marriage supporters because Hennepin County District Judge Mary DuFresne had dismissed the case on all counts.
“The appeals court ruling is obviously something we’re very pleased about. Now the case will go back to the lower court where we’ll have the opportunity to make our case based on the merits of the case, rather than just judicial maneuvering,” said Douglas Benson, who filed the lawsuit with his partner Duane Gajewski and two other couples.
“We expect the opportunity for full discovery, testimony, exhibits, evidence and a full-scale hearing on the merit, similar to the case of Perry v. Schwarzenegger,” the gay marriage case in California, said Minneapolis attorney Peter Nickitas, who is representing the Benson appellants.
Chuck Laszewski, spokesman for Hennepin County Attorney’s office, which represents Jill Alverson, the county registrar and respondent, said they were looking over the ruling very carefully, but had no further comment.
Monday’s unpublished ruling, which means it cannot be cited in other cases, arrives as efforts are heating up over a November ballot measure that would change the Minnesota Constitution to say that only man-woman marriages are legal.
The Benson case “is exactly the type of case that has resulted in same-sex marriage being imposed in other states, and highlights the need to enact the Marriage Protection Amendment in November,” said Jason Adkins, executive director of the Minnesota Catholic Conference and vice chairman of Minnesota for Marriage, which is promoting the amendment.
“Voters can make sure that this courts ruling is not the final word. The final word belongs to the people of Minnesota, not judges,” said Jordan Lorence, senior counsel at the Alliance Defense Fund, which represented the Minnesota Family Council in a friend-of-the-court brief in support of traditional marriage.
The case was filed after Ms. Alverson denied marriage licenses to the three same-sex couples. They sued, saying that Minnesota’s 1997 Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) violated their rights to freedom of conscience, due process, equal treatment and freedom of association.
Judge DuFresne dismissed all these claims in her March 2011 ruling, in part because a 1971 Minnesota Supreme Court ruling, Baker v. Nelson, said man-woman marriage did not offend the U.S. Constitution. Since Minnesota’s state constitution is similar to the U.S. Constitution, it is unlikely there is a right in it to gay marriage, either, the judge reasoned.
The appellate court judges agreed that the appellants’ conscience rights were not being violated. “But because the district court inappropriately dismissed the matter at this early stage of litigation, we reverse and remand the remaining claims,” they wrote.
© Copyright 2014 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.
About the Author
Cheryl Wetzstein covers family and social issues as a national reporter for The Washington Times. She has been a reporter for three decades, working in New York City and Washington, D.C. Since joining The Washington Times in 1985, she has been a features writer, environmental and consumer affairs reporter, and assistant business editor.
Beginning in 1994, Mrs. Wetzstein worked exclusively ...
- Divided court strikes down big porn award
- 10 million new babies? China's hope for boom likely to become policy bust
- Judge voids N. Dakota's 'heartbeat' abortion law
- Family, agency in custody battle over sick daughter
- Values group wins court round over use of gay marriage photo
Latest Blog Entries
- Gay therapy ban author seeks Calif. House seat
- Transgender 'bathroom law' gets 5,000 more signatures
- Pro-life, stem-cell bill signed into law by Kansas Gov. Sam Brownback
- N. Dakota lawmakers approve tough abortion bill
- Pope Benedict XVI's successor should allow priests to get a new title: Husband, poll finds
TWT Video Picks
By Tammy Bruce
Only IRS employees could expect rewards for failing to pay their taxes
- Holder cancels appearance in OKC amid angry protests
- 'Top Gun' for drones: Squadrons of carrier-based killers have Navy's approval
- In its hunt for Senate, Republican candidates campaign against Harry Reid
- America is an oligarchy, not a democracy or republic, university study finds
- Obamacare class-action suit opens a new legal front
- Sold out: Ukraine's leadership swapped best military weapons for cash
- Justice at last: 'Evil woman' outed for grabbing girl's game ball
- Gun control supporters send message to NRA
- Nevada rancher Cliven Bundy hailed as patriot, ripped as lawless deadbeat
- Nevada rancher's racial remarks cost him range of support
Top 10 handguns in the U.S.
Celebrity deaths in 2014