You are currently viewing the printable version of this article, to return to the normal page, please click here.

Pennsylvania’s voter-I.D. law challenged in court

- Associated Press - Tuesday, May 1, 2012

HARRISBURG, Pa. — Pennsylvania's tough new voter-identification law was challenged in court Tuesday by 10 registered voters, including some who say they are unable to get the kind of ID now required and one woman who said she had to pay for one despite the law's promise of a free photo ID.

The lawsuit, filed in the state's Commonwealth Court, said the law violates the state constitution's "free and equal" elections clause and another clause that establishes qualifications to vote in Pennsylvania.

"Many otherwise qualified voters will face great difficulty or be unable to obtain the necessary ID and will therefore be disenfranchised in the upcoming general election and future elections," the suit said. "As a result, far from protecting the integrity of Pennsylvania elections, the photo ID law will lead to elections that are no longer free and equal."

The lawsuit seeks an injunction that halts the enforcement of the law and documents examples of people having a hard time getting the free photo ID that the state promises under the law. Lawyers from the American Civil Liberties Union and the Public Interest Law Center of Philadelphia are helping represent the plaintiffs.

Gov. Tom Corbett on March 14 signed the bill — one of the nation's toughest voter-ID laws — after it passed the GOP-controlled state Legislature over the objections of Democrats, the AARP, the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, labor unions and good-government groups.

Opponents of the law call it a throwback to the now-unconstitutional poll taxes and literacy tests designed to discriminate against poor and minority voters and a thinly veiled attempt to defeat President Obama in the Nov. 6 election, when Pennsylvania, historically a swing state, is again expected to be a high-profile battleground.

Republicans, who for years have harbored suspicions of widespread voter fraud in the Democratic bastion of Philadelphia, say the law is a common-sense measure to ensure the integrity of the balloting and that photo IDs are regularly used in day-to-day activity.

But, the lawsuit said, it will result in a large-scale disenfranchisement that will cast doubt on the integrity of Pennsylvania's election results.

"With no evidence of any meaningful in-person voter fraud, the photo ID law is a cure in search of a nonexistent disease," the suit said. "But the supposed cure itself threatens to kill the patient — namely, the integrity of elections in Pennsylvania."

The Corbett administration has said it believes the law will withstand a court challenge. The nine-member Commonwealth Court is composed of seven Republicans and two Democrats.

Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.