Israel’s fence puts irrigation in jeopardy

West Bank uses terracing system from Roman times to grow crops

Question of the Day

Is it still considered bad form to talk politics during a social gathering?

View results

BATTIR, West Bank — One of the last Palestinian farming villages that still uses irrigation systems from Roman times says its ancient way of life is in danger as Israel prepares to lay down its West Bank separation barrier.

With construction possibly beginning in the coming weeks, the people of Battir hope a legal battle, backed by recent U.N. recognition of the village’s agricultural practices, will help change Israel’s mind.

Battir’s 6,000 inhabitants live in limestone-faced houses built into a hillside southwest of Jerusalem.

On land around the homes, stone retaining walls have transformed scrubby hills into orderly terraces of olive trees and vegetable gardens.

Terraces are a common Palestinian farming technique in the hilly West Bank terrain. But in Battir, they are unique for their extent - stretching uninterrupted across nearly 800 acres - and for the centuries-old network of irrigation canals that direct springwater over the stepped hills.

This combination prompted the U.N.’s cultural agency, UNESCO, to award the village last year a $15,000 prize for “safeguarding and management of cultural landscapes.”

The canal network has been in place for 2,000 years, with residents continually keeping up the system, said Giovanni Fontana-Antonelli, a local UNESCO official.

Land issues

Because the area is largely untouched by construction, it is still possible to see “the form and the shape of the past generations’ work,” Mr. Fontana-Antonelli said. “In other places you have terraces, but you also have urban sprawl, roads and settlements.

“The wall as projected so far will interfere with this ancient irrigation system by cutting part of the irrigation network,” he said of the planned path for Israel’s barrier. The integrity of the terraces “will be totally dismantled.”

Israel began building the barrier in 2002 in response to a wave of deadly suicide bombings carried out by Palestinians who had entered from the West Bank.

Planned to stretch 500 miles, it is about two-thirds complete, according to Shaul Arieli, a retired military officer who now advises the Supreme Court on the barrier.

Israelis say the structure is a main reason for the halt in suicide bombings in recent years.

But Palestinians argue it is a pretext for Israel to steal their land.

Nearly 10 percent of the West Bank, which the Palestinians claim for a future state, will lie on the “Israeli” side of the barrier when it is complete.

For this reason, construction on several stretches of the barrier have been delayed for legal appeals.

Battir presents a particular challenge because the village’s homes are in the West Bank while the fields are partially in Israel. This anomaly was enshrined in the 1949 cease-fire that ended Israel’s war of independence.

Legal challenge ahead

Current plans show that the barrier will run close to the 1949 boundary and leave about 160 acres of village lands on the Israeli side, according to the Israeli Defense Ministry.

Village council chief Akram Bader estimates more than twice that amount of land will end up on the Israeli side. Mr. Bader, an architect, used Google Earth and land confiscation orders to calculate the higher figure.

He said the Defense Ministry estimate fails to account for the West Bank land that will be gobbled up.

In 2007, Battir sued the state and Defense Ministry, demanding it change the route of the fence in order to protect the unique farming area.

In the legal documents, Israel claimed Battir is a tempting area for Palestinian attackers to penetrate Israel.

The state also insisted on keeping control of a nearby rail line running from Jerusalem to Tel Aviv. It was built before Israel’s independence.

A Defense Ministry official said the barrier’s planners have met with Battir’s residents and tried to take their concerns into account.

He said the barrier will not disrupt farming because an access gate will be open to Battir’s farmers three times a day. He spoke on the condition of anonymity because of ongoing legal proceedings.

Early this year, Battir suspended a challenge in Israel’s Supreme Court so a separate advisory commission under the Finance Ministry could consider their request to cancel the expropriation of their farmland and reroute the barrier onto Israeli lands. The committee has not ruled.

In the meantime, defense officials say they plan to begin construction in the coming weeks.

Battir’s lawyer, Ghiath Nasser, said the village will seek a court order to block construction until the legal process is exhausted.

Palestinians have had mixed results in past court challenges.

Bilin, a village west of Ramallah, initially lost half its land to the barrier.

But in 2007, the high court ordered the Israeli government to move Bilin’s barrier westward toward Israel. It took three years before the government did so.

Many other villages have failed to change the barrier’s path, such as Battir’s neighbor Walajeh, where Israel is surrounding the village with a wall and fence on all sides.

Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Comments
blog comments powered by Disqus
TWT Video Picks