- Associated Press - Tuesday, May 29, 2012

WASHINGTON (AP) - They’re throwing granny off a cliff!

That’s the not-so-subtle message Republicans and Democrats seem to be converging on for political ads on health care this year, featuring heavy doses of what each side alleges the other will do to wreck Medicare.

From President Barack Obama’s overhaul law to GOPRep. Paul Ryan’s privatization plan for future Medicare recipients, there’s something about health care legislation that makes it a breeding ground for wild allegations.

Families feel vulnerable to the catastrophic costs of serious illness, and few understand the labyrinth of private and government insurance, allowing partisans to fan their worst fears. Political pros play on health care worries to sway older voters.

“It is easy to deceive on the issue because the knowledge base of the electorate when it comes to the complexities of health care is relatively low,” said Kathleen Hall Jamieson, an expert on political communication at the University of Pennsylvania's Annenberg Center.

It would be hard to top Sarah Palin’s now-debunked assertion that “death panels” lurked in the recesses of Obama’s law, but don’t be surprised if that happens.

“Many people believe crazy things about health care because they want to believe them,” said Drew Altman, president of the nonpartisan Kaiser Family Foundation. Today’s outlandish claims remind him of fears about fluoridated drinking water in the 1950s.

Sound far-fetched? It’s already started.

Earlier this year, former Republican presidential candidate Rick Santorum lent credence to an unfounded rumor that the Obama administration would deny advanced treatment to stroke patients over the age of 70, allowing only comfort care. It didn’t seem to matter that two doctors’ groups and the Health and Human Services Department refuted the rumor.

And as for throwing granny off a cliff, two political ads are already depicting that _ one from the left and one from the right. Both dramatizations are getting attention on the Internet.

The ad from the left, by The Agenda Project, features an actress playing an elderly woman in a wheelchair. Pushing her is a younger man acting the part of Ryan, R-Wis. “America the Beautiful” plays in the background.

But the outing to a scenic overlook turns scary when he steers for the edge. She tries to fight, but he dumps her over the cliff. The caption urges viewers to let Ryan know America wouldn’t be beautiful without Medicare.

The ad from the right, by AmericanDoctors4Truth, shows an actor representing Obama pushing an elderly woman in a wheelchair off a cliff, after she demands a pacemaker recommended by her doctor.

The ad takes things to another level by using a snippet of Obama’s voice. It comes from a rambling response the president gave in 2009 to a woman who wanted to know how his health plan might affect patients like her mother, who got a pacemaker at the age of 100 and enjoyed a good life.

A transcript of the town hall-style meeting shows that Obama didn’t directly answer the question. At one point he suggests if there’s waste involved it would be better to tell patients “you know what, maybe this isn’t going to help, maybe you’re better off not having the surgery, but taking the painkiller.”

Story Continues →