- Marco Rubio: U.S. at social, moral crossroads
- ‘We’re coming for you, Barack Obama’: Top U.S. official discloses threat from ISIL
- White flags baffle NYPD: ‘We’re lucky it wasn’t a bomb’
- N.Y. Gov. Cuomo’s office interfered with, pressured corruption commission: report
- Brit lawmaker: I would fire on Israel if I lived in Gaza
- VA apologizes to forgotten Marine veteran locked in Fla. clinic, forced to call 911
- U.S. social and economic trends on worrisome track, survey finds
- McDonald nomination unanimously referred to full Senate
- Chuck Norris honorary chairman of NRA voter registration campaign
- GOP outraged Obamacare investigators able to get coverage with fake IDs
Indiana justices weigh vouchers
Teachers union’s challenge hinges on who benefits
Question of the Day
INDIANAPOLIS — Indiana Supreme Court justices weighing the legality of the nation’s largest school-voucher program made clear during a packed hearing Wednesday that the program’s fate may rest on whether it primarily benefits students’ parents or the religious institutions that run private schools.
The five justices prodded lawyers for both sides on the vouchers’ consequences as they heard a constitutional challenge to the 2011 law, under which more than 9,000 students have switched from public to private schools with help from state funds. The program was pushed by Gov. Mitch Daniels and is considered a model of conservative Republicans’ approach to overhauling education.
State Solicitor General Thomas Fisher, defending the law, said the vouchers allow parents to send their children to private schools they otherwise couldn’t afford. He said parents, not the state, decide which schools receive public voucher money.
“Any money that ends up in the coffers of religious institutions is there at the discretion of the parent,” Mr. Fisher said during the hourlong hearing.
But John West, the Washington lawyer handling the court challenge pressed by the Indiana State Teachers Association, said that virtually all of the voucher money goes to schools whose primary purpose is to promote the teachings of their affiliated churches.
“Here, the state is directly paying for the teaching of religion,” Mr. West said. “Many of these schools describe themselves as ministries of the churches they’re affiliated with,” he added.
The Indiana case is being closely watched because the vouchers are available to middle-class students. Voucher programs in other states are generally limited to low-income students or those in failing schools. Conservative Republicans say the vouchers offer families more choices and will boost education by giving public schools greater incentive to improve. Critics contend the vouchers could cripple public schools by diverting desperately needed funds.
In considering the law, “The problem for me is ‘the benefit of,’” said Indiana Chief Justice Brent Dickson, referring the wording of the state constitution, which precludes spending state funds for the benefit of religious institutions. Chief Justice Dickson and other justices repeatedly probed the nuances of that phrase’s meaning — including whether it applied to other government services or to state scholarships that help students attend church-affiliated universities like Notre Dame.
“Why is that permissible, and this is not?” Chief Justice Dickson asked. He also noted that in 1851, when the constitution was ratified, most of the state’s schools were private and “the Bible was the textbook.”
Mr. West argued that in those other cases, the state wasn’t directly funding religious activity.
Justice Stephen David focused on whether the state will have shifted to a religious education system if the vouchers drain much of the resources from public schools.
“What if 97 percent of kids end up going to religious schools?” he asked Mr. Fisher. “That is altering the state of education.”
“You still have decisions being made by the parents,” Mr. Fisher insisted. He also said the question was hypothetical.
However, Fort Wayne Community Schools Board President Mark GiaQuinta said after the hearing that school vouchers already had damaged the state’s largest public school district.
“We have lost $7 million of our budget to vouchers,” he told reporters. The district’s 2013 budget is $279 million.
TWT Video Picks
The subsidies are a hit with patients who don't exist
- CARSON: Costco and the perils of mixing politics and business
- Democratic Sen. John Walsh plagiarized War College master's thesis: report
- House task force to recommend National Guard on border, faster deportations
- Obama orders Pentagon advisers to Ukraine
- Netanyahu's Wikipedia page replaced with giant Palestinian flag
- 'We're coming for you, Barack Obama': Top U.S. official discloses threat from ISIL terrorists
- DEACE: How to go from civil rights icon to bigot in one quote
- Beretta moving to Tennessee over Maryland gun laws
- Two Ukrainian fighter jets shot down
- Latest Obama claim: I don't learn anything from the news
Obama's biggest White House 'fails'
Celebrities turned politicians
Athletes turned actors
20 gadgets that changed the world
Fighting in Iraq