MUSIC REVIEWS: Alicia Keys, Serena Ryder
Girl on Fire
Alicia Keys was the best-selling R&B artist of the past decade, selling more than 20 million albums in America alone. Times change and genres evolve, though, and R&B is a different animal today than it was in 2001, when Miss Keys released her first record.
Album cover for Serena Ryder “Harmony”. more >
Maybe that’s why she’s so intent on reinventing herself with “Girl on Fire.” The soulful, jazzy piano ballads that have been her bread and butter for years haven’t gone anywhere, but they’re just a piece of the puzzle on this eclectic album, which leans heavily on hip-hop and electro soul. A pulsing, throbbing beat runs beneath at least half of the songs, which physically shake Miss Keys off her piano stool and push her onto the dance floor.
The liner notes look like the guest list from some music-biz Christmas party. Dr. Dre and Salaam Remi, the latter of whom helped launch Amy Winehouse’s career, share production duties with at least five others. Nicki Minaj makes a guest appearance on the rap-heavy title track, and Maxwell sings along with Miss Keys‘ raspy, wholehearted croon on “Fire We Make.” Gary Clark, Jr., the industry’s newest blues guitar hero, stops by to play a few licks, too.
Miss Keys is still the queen on this star-studded album, although she doesn’t always sound comfortable in her new raiment. “Limitedless” has all the Caribbean flavor of a Rihanna single, but it sounds odd coming from Miss Keys, who sings the song with a faux Jamaican accent. Is imitation the only path to reinvention?
Luckily, Miss Keys blazes her own trail on songs such as “When It’s All Over,” a stylistic mash-up that pairs jazz drums and buzzing electronics with a gorgeous melody line. “New Day” does something similar, trading out the jazzy percussion for something more akin to a marching band. Then there’s “Listen To Your Heart,” a gorgeous slow jam steeped in D’Angelo’s slow, sultry dynamics.
Old-school fans are in luck, too. Miss Keys hasn’t forgotten her roots, and she throws a bone to longtime supporters on tunes such as “Tears Always Win,” a Motown-influenced soul number, and “Not Even the King,” a solo piano ballad about money, royalty and love.
“Girl on Fire” may be focused on the future, not the past, but it bridges the gap nicely. Here’s to another decade.