- Obama downplays IRS scandal, blames Obamacare rollout on ‘outdated’ agencies
- Pregnancies decline overall, up among older women
- Pentagon plans to destroy Syrian chemical arms on ship at sea
- Paris Metro issues ‘politeness manual’ to improve passengers’ behavior
- Justin Bieber, crew detained at Australian airport in drug search
- Lee Rigby trial: Muslim who machete-hacked soldier calls it ‘humane’ kill
- GM ending Chevy sales in Europe to focus on Opel and Vauxhall
- Putin’s diplomats to U.S. busted for living high life off $1.5M bilked from Medicaid
- Happy Meal: Couple goes to McDonald’s, leaves with bag packed with cash
- Boehner: It took me 3 to 4 hours to sign up for Obamacare
High court to again consider racial quotas
For the first time in nearly a decade, the issue of race as a factor in college admissions comes before the Supreme Court on Wednesday, thrusting affirmative action back into the national spotlight.
The justices will begin hearing arguments Wednesday in the closely watched Fisher vs. the University of Texas case, which, if the court rules broadly, could have far-reaching consequences for hiring and other policies beyond higher education.
“It’s likely, I think, to perhaps become the most important case in history on racial preferences,” said Stuart Taylor Jr., a Supreme Court scholar and co-author of the new book “Mismatch,” which examines affirmative action and its use by institutions of higher education.
The case was brought by a white college student, Abigail Fisher, who contends that her civil rights were violated after she was denied entry to the university because of her skin color. Ms. Fisher has since graduated from Louisiana State University but told The New York Times in a rare interview this week that she was “devastated” by her rejection to the University of Texas, her family school.
The school admits nearly all students who finish in the top 10 percent of their high school classes. The remaining spots are awarded based on a variety factors, including the university’s effort to achieve racial diversity on its campuses.
Ms. Fisher argues that the school accepted students of lower academic achievement solely because of their skin color and ignored her above-average grades only because she is white.
Many other schools use similar systems. The high court ruled in 2003 that the University of Michigan Law School could use race as one of several factors in deciding whom to admit, though specific racial quotas aren’t allowed.
That ruling has over the past nine years generated more confusion and controversy over what colleges can and cannot consider when choosing their students.
Proponents of racial considerations believe they are necessary to forge a pathway into college for many minority and low-income students, particularly those who come from poor school systems. Many also argue that they help form a diverse student body, thereby enriching the educational experience of all pupils.
Critics, however, say they are a form of racial discrimination and an impediment to students such as Ms. Fisher, who themselves become disadvantaged because of race.
“Even if there are some educational benefits [to having more minority students], they have got to be weighed against the costs that are inherent in engaging in this discrimination,” said Roger Clegg, president and general counsel of the Center for Equal Opportunity, speaking at an affirmative action panel discussion Tuesday at the Cato Institute.
Mr. Clegg and many others support the outright elimination of all racial preferences in college admissions and hopes the court strikes them down once and for all in the Fisher case.
Dramatic changes in the makeup of the Supreme Court since its 2003 decision could offer some clues to which way the justices will rule. Those changes are, for racial-preference opponents, a reason to be optimistic.
In 2007, the court struck down a Seattle system that divided the city’s elementary-school students equally along racial lines. Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., who wrote the majority opinion, called those methods “extreme.” In 2009, the court ruled that New Haven, Conn., violated the civil rights of 20 firefighters after it threw out the results of a promotion exam because not enough blacks had passed it.
With liberal-leaning Justice Elena Kagan recusing herself from the case — she worked on it at a lower-court level as the Obama administration’s solicitor general — the key vote could again lie with Justice Anthony M. Kennedy.
© Copyright 2013 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.
About the Author
Ben Wolfgang covers the White House for The Washington Times.
Before joining the Times in March 2011, Ben spent four years as a political reporter at the Republican-Herald in Pottsville, Pa.
He can be reached at email@example.com.
- Obama: Nelson Mandela now 'belongs to the ages'
- Obama lived with Uncle Onyango Obama in the 1980s, White House admits
- Obama calls on bartenders to help sell health care reform
- Obama returns to class warfare as poll numbers plunge
- Obama: 'We're not going back' on Obamacare
Latest Blog Entries
- 'Hunger Games' delivers Obama's message on income inequality: liberal group
- NAPOLITANO: Pope Francis should be saving souls, not pocketbooks
- Obama returns to class warfare as poll numbers plunge
- Inside China: Nuclear submarines capable of widespread attack on U.S.
- CARSON: Getting to the top by starting at the bottom
- U.S. drops 2,000 mice on Guam by parachute to kill snakes
- Russian diplomats busted bilking $1.5 million from Medicaid
- CURL: 'Mission Accomplished' for Obamacare
- U.S. pilot scares off Iranians with 'Top Gun'-worthy stunt: 'You really ought to go home'
- U.S. debt jumps a record $328 billion tops $17 trillion for first time
Independent voices from the The Washington Times Communities
Interviews and show reviews from the Los Angeles punk scene past and present. Los Angeles has always been rich in punk rock talent since punk rock was born.
NFL junkie Eric Golub reports on his favorite obsession. There is no football offseason. Every February he pretends to care about other sports while sobbing uncontrollably each Sunday until September.
All of the world’s problems, solved on your back porch
Brazen, leading-edge, “call it like it is” columns and reporting from Ohio native, radio host and writer, Sara Marie Brenner.
White House pets gone wild!