- Florida beach-goers told to beware flesh-eating bacteria in water
- Lundergan Grimes uses ‘war on women’ strategy to attack McConnell
- Rep. Jeff Miller: ‘Ain’t no leash for VA’
- Al Qaeda nets $125M from ransom payoffs from Europe since 2008
- Ohio Gov. John Kasich cruising to re-election: survey
- Landslide hits Indian village; 150 may be trapped
- Albania bank loses $7M in theft; police arrest 2
- Gov. Mike Pence irked as Obama sends illegals to Indiana on sly
- Israel, White House say Obama phone call to demand cease-fire was fake
- Nancy Pelosi: Deporting kids un-Christian, sends them ‘into a burning building’
Free-speech zone proves audience-free
Protesters mull value of platform for civil liberty
Question of the Day
CHARLOTTE, N.C. — Standing atop a creaky wooden platform above a muddy, fenced-in field, protester Bob Kunst gave a dozen or so cardboard rubbish bins near the Democratic National Convention a piece of his mind.
Mr. Kunst criticized American policy toward Israel. He warned against Iran acquiring nuclear weapons. As a countdown clock ticked away, he struggled to be heard — in part because the field was completely empty, in part because a nearby gas-powered generator all but drowned out his words.
When Mr. Kunst finished speaking, a trash bag blew across the grassy expanse, designated by the city as a “free speech zone.”
“They said if the scheduled speaker didn’t show up, I could speak,” said Mr. Kunst, a 70-year-old Miami Beach, Fla., resident and president of Shalom International, a pro-Israel group.
Like many cities that have hosted large political gatherings — including Tampa, Fla, home to last week’s Republican National Convention — Charlotte has created an official area where protesters are allowed to speak.
Located on a plot of undeveloped land down the street from the Charlotte Convention Center and next to a highway, the city’s “speaker’s platform” gives activists a 30-minute window to express their opinions through city-provided loudspeakers.
Ostensibly constructed to enhance convention security, the platform has produced a civil liberties riddle: If protesters such as Mr. Kunst exercise their First Amendment rights in a deserted designated zone, do they actually make a sound?
“The notion of being relegated to a fenced-off area in a government-designated free-speech zone is troubling,” said Michael Zytkow, a 26-year-old Charlotte resident and Occupy Charlotte organizer. “So many people have fought for us to have and keep these freedoms.”
More than a dozen groups and individuals have signed up for speaking slots, which were assigned via a lottery drawing earlier this year.
Activists, however, have criticized both the concept and location of the platform, which sits more than a half-mile from Time Warner Cable Arena, home to the first two nights of the DNC.
According to Mr. Zytkow, a number of activists from the Occupy movement and the Coalition to March on Wall Street South have signed up for slots they have no intention of using.
That includes Mr. Zytkow, who intends to leave something symbolic — a picture, a sign, perhaps an empty chair — on the platform during his upcoming evening speaking slot.
“It’s always difficult to balance security and free speech, but the process they used to let people speak was the same as giving away an iPod at a bingo hall,” he said, “and activists were completely left out of choosing a location.
“So a number of us decided to jam the system, kind of making a mockery of the whole thing. Not only are we boycotting participating within the free speech zone, but you won’t see people even coming to listen.”
That much was evident yesterday afternoon, as Mr. Kunst and Steve Widdows — a self-described “street preacher” discussing “sodomy, abortion and fornication” — spoke to no one and a single curious television camera crew, respectively.
© Copyright 2014 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.
About the Author
Patrick Hruby is an award-winning journalist who holds degrees from Georgetown and Northwestern. He also contributes to ESPN.com and The Atlantic Online, and his work has been featured in The Best American Sports Writing. Follow him on Twitter (@patrick_hruby) and contact him at PatrickHruby.net.
- Taking to Twitter: Everybody's Oscar night in 140 characters
- Glenn Beck, Michelle Malkin cry foul at WWE Tea Party stereotypes
- Oscar Pistorius and the 'roid rage' defense: It's no Get-Out-Of-Jail-Free card
- Spatial media: Astronaut Chris Hadfield live chats from 220 miles above earth
- Hero-worship for a cold-blooded killer: The cult of Christopher Dorner
TWT Video Picks
- Boehner rules out impeachment: 'Scam started by Democrats'
- Patent workers paid to exercise, shop, do chores: report
- Fla. mom arrested for allowing 7-year-old son to walk to park alone
- CARSON: Rudderless U.S. foreign policy
- Obama thanks Muslims for 'building the very fabric of our nation'
- Obama mum on where illegal immigrant children are sheltered
- Smugglers, rainstorm combine to poke holes in border fence
- Defense lawyer: McDonnell's wife had 'crush' on CEO
- Federal judge grants 90-day stay in D.C. gun case
- Feds sue Pennsylvania State Police over women's fitness tests
Obama's biggest White House 'fails'
Celebrities turned politicians
Athletes turned actors
20 gadgets that changed the world