- Kentucky city called socialist for buying gas station, undercutting competitor fuel prices
- Israel hits five mosques, sports complex in overnight Gaza strikes
- Hillary Clinton dogged for refusing reporters’ questions on book tour
- EPA tweet baffles: ‘I’m now a C-List celebrity in Kim Kardashian: Hollywood’ iPhone game
- Australian P.M. Abbott: MH17 evidence tampered with on ‘industrial scale’
- Rep. Luis Gutierrez tells Hispanics to vote and ‘punish those’ who oppose amnesty
- Country singer Tim McGraw not sorry for slapping female fan: ‘Things happen’
- Iraq vet cited for owning 14 therapeutic pet ducks
- White House takes credit for drop in unaccompanied children at border
- International crises be damned, Obama’s fundraising trip must go on
FEULNER: ‘The Trial,’ American-style
Who can avoid running afoul of overcriminalization?
Question of the Day
At one time in history, there was a general belief in the Divine Right of Kings. Whatever the king or ruler decided at that moment was the law. Thus, standards were constantly changing.
Because “power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely,” in the immortal words of Lord Acton, laws handed down by kings were often arbitrary, unfair, unjust and cruel.
In America, the Founders recognized that the first requirement for civil society is order. We enjoy a system of ordered liberty, where the rules are spelled out, written down and equally applied to everyone.
The principle of equality in the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution refers to equality before the law. This is why it is said that in America, justice is blind. Because the law is objective and written down, all Americans are subject to it equally, regardless of their economic or social background.
Unfortunately, as the size and scope of government have grown, it has become next to impossible for ordinary, law-abiding citizens to carry on their lives and businesses without violating some obscure law and quite possibly going to jail for their “crime.”
Today, neither the Justice Department nor the Congressional Research Service can even count the number of crimes in federal law. There is simply no way the average citizen can know what to do to avoid becoming a federal criminal.
It’s a situation reminiscent of “The Trial,” a literary classic written in German by the Czech author Franz Kafka and published in 1925. It tells the story of a man prosecuted by an inaccessible authority for a crime whose nature is never revealed to him.
Today, the adjective “Kafkaesque” is often used to describe absurd, nightmarish situations in which an isolated, helpless individual is harassed by remote and inscrutable powers for reasons he can barely fathom.
Kafka’s “The Trial” is a work of fiction, but the Kafkaesque ordeal undergone by honest, law-abiding Abner Schoenwetter, who had the great misfortune of running afoul of the tendency of some politicians to overcriminalize unintentional violations of the law, was all too real.
Mr. Schoenwetter spent 69 months in federal prison for doing something that he never suspected was illegal: importing undersized lobsters from Honduras and packaging them in plastic rather than in boxes, as required by law.
Federal lawmakers heard firsthand about his ordeal when he testified in 2010 before the House Judiciary Committee. He explained how he was found guilty, sentenced to more than eight years in prison, and ordered to pay a $15,000 fine and a $100,000 forfeiture, which he had to remortgage his house to be able to pay.
Tragically, Mr. Schoenwetter’s experience is far from unique. There are:
The father-and-son arrowhead collectors who are now federal criminals because they unknowingly violated the Archaeological Resources Protection Act 1979.
The aspiring inventor who spent 15 months in prison for environmental crimes, even though he neither harmed nor intended to harm anyone.
The Pennsylvania woman who injured her husband’s lover and now faces federal charges related to an international arms-control treaty.
© Copyright 2014 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.
About the Author
TWT Video Picks
U.S. appetite for drugs begets violence migrants are fleeing
Get Breaking Alerts
- IRS seeks help destroying another 3,200 computer hard drives
- Jewish woman booted from JetBlue flight over fight with Palestinian
- YOUNG: A sinking presidency, deeper after November?
- PRUDEN: A deadly enemy within exacerbating immigration crisis
- Edward Snowden to work with Russia on anti-spy technology
- MERRY: Handicaps in Hillary's way
- U.S. scrambles as violence escalates in Israel-Hamas conflict
- Humanists seek support from Congress on military chaplains
- Rep. Jared Polis' anti-fracking crusade riles Colorado
- Big milestone for Britain's little prince