- - Sunday, December 15, 2013

ANALYSIS/OPINION:

The debate about comprehensive immigration reform keeps coming up, and while efforts to pass this sweeping legislation have failed several times, it is likely to be an issue for the next session of Congress.

One of the national authorities on immigration is Michael Cutler, a retired senior special agent with the Immigration and Naturalization Service whose career spanned some 30 years. He has provided testimony to the Sept. 11 Commission and has been called to testify before more than a dozen House and Senate hearings to provide his perspectives and concerns borne of his extensive career with the INS, an agency that was broken up in 2003.


SPECIAL COVERAGE: Immigration Reform


He testified most recently before the Senate on March 20, on the topic of building an immigration system worthy of American values. On March 19, 2002, he testified before the House Judiciary subcommittee on immigration, border security and claims.

That hearing, “INS’s March 2002 Notification of Approval of Change of Status for Pilot Training for Terrorist Hijackers Mohammed Atta and Marwan Al-Shehhi,” captured the attention of news organizations around the world. A C-SPAN video provides a compelling image of incompetence at the INS that was impossible to ignore.

Mr. Cutler agreed to participate in an exclusive interview on his perspectives and concerns about comprehensive immigration reform and explains why he has been consistently opposed to this legislation.

Q. How important is the immigration issue?

A. It is arguably the most serious issue confronting the United States today — bar none.

America’s borders and immigration laws exist for two primary purposes: to protect innocent lives and protect the jobs of American workers.

Immigration is not a single issue but a singular issue that impacts virtually every challenge and threat confronting America and Americans today. National security and public safety are undermined by failures to secure America’s borders, enforce the immigration laws along its borders and from within the interior of the United States and create true integrity to the processes by which aliens are provided with visas and lawful status in the United States including those who are permitted to attend school, work on jobs for which they have been granted appropriate visas, be granted permission to remain permanently in the United States as refugees who are given political asylum, lawful immigrant status and United States citizenship.

These failures also negatively impact America’s economy, driving down wages and increasing unemployment and underemployment. Other issues to be considered are the impact on education, health care, public health and the environment.

By the way, before we continue with our conversation we need to do a bit of semantic housekeeping. Ever since the administration of President Jimmy Carter, the term “alien” has been under attack. Under his administration, INS employees were told to stop referring to illegal aliens as being illegal aliens.

I am a big fan of being politically correct if the goal is not embarrass or demean another person. However, the term “alien” is not a pejorative. Under the Immigration and Nationality Act, the all-encompassing body of the immigration laws of the United States, the term alien is simply defined as being “any person, not a citizen or national of the United States.” There is absolutely no insult in that definition, only clarity.

Those who seek to dismantle America’s border and ignore America’s immigration laws understand that the laws, the facts, the truth, common sense and morality all oppose their unsupportable and unjustifiable positions. While some are misguided and don’t truly understand the true importance and need for effective border security and effective immigration law enforcement, most are driven by unbridled greed.

The easiest way I can prove the real importance of our immigration laws is to call your attention to a specific section of the Immigration and Nationality Act, (Title 8, United States Code, Section 1182) that establishes the categories of aliens who are to be excluded from the United States. It is vital to note that there is absolutely no distinction made about race, religion or ethnicity.

Story Continues →