FENNO: NCAA-Electronic Arts fallout could make every avatar a ‘Johnny Football’

Question of the Day

What has been the biggest debacle on Obama's watch?

View results


Meet QB No. 2.

Maybe you’ve seen the soon-to-be redshirt sophomore at Texas A&M. Legs that churn like a running back and a strong right arm that’s made for coach Kevin Sumlin’s “Air Raid” offense.

The quarterback exists in the video game world of Electronic Arts‘ NCAA Football 2014 and, of course, is known in the non-pixelated world as Johnny Manziel. His digital doppelganger wears the same maroon and white No. 2 jersey, looks like him, runs like him, throws like him and weighs within five pounds of the actual Johnny Football. All that’s supposed to be a coincidence.

“The NCAA has never licensed the use of current student-athlete names, images or likenesses to EA,” the NCAA insisted in a press release Wednesday that’d send anyone who has spent five minutes with the video game into fits of eye-rolling.

Manziel doesn’t see a dime from the game that mimics him and generates revenue for everyone from the NCAA to Electronic Arts. Like the rest of us, the quarterback has to shell out $59.99 for a copy. Never mind that the Heisman Trophy winner is a key part of the product, along with hundreds of other big-name players. The NCAA’s make-believe amateurism insists that if Manziel received a cut of the game’s profits — even a complimentary copy — the earth would be knocked off its axis.

Faced with the not-too-distant prospect of actually sharing those proceeds, the NCAA instead declined to renew its contract with Electronic Arts on Wednesday. That’s the equivalent of kicking over video game controllers and sulking home — which, in this case, resembles a money bin, given the organization’s $871.6 million in 2012 revenue.

That rampant use of likenesses of current and former college athletes without compensation is at the heart of Ed O'Bannon’s long-running antitrust lawsuit against the NCAA and others. The case could transform college athletics and the NCAA’s hasty exit from the Electronic Arts deal is the first significant ripple outside the courtroom. This one, however, landed in your living room.

“We are confident in our legal position regarding the use of our trademarks in video games,” the NCAA’s press release said. “But given the current business climate and costs of litigation, we determined participating in this game is not in the best interests of the NCAA.”

Translation: admitting we’re wrong and giving athletes a cut of the proceeds (and, in the process, ending the amateurism charade) will cost more than simply ending the contract.

“They say they’re feeling confident about not giving away those rights, but their actions speak louder than their press release,” said Warren Zola, who teaches sports law at Boston College’s Carroll School of Management. “There’s no doubt this move was done, in part, to reduce potential liability.”

Emails revealed in the O’Bannon case show the liability worry is long-standing. There’s no accident to QB No. 2 having everything but Manziel’s name.

“I’m not an attorney,” former NCAA membership services staffer Bo Kerin wrote in a 2005 note, “but you will recall several in the room who are expressed real concern that this adds to the argument that student-athletes should be unionized and receive a cut of the profits, etc.”

In other emails, Electronic Arts staffers discussed using player likenesses and NCAA staffers admitted as much. But the legal heat generated by the O’Bannon case has grown in recent months, as the parties await Judge Claudia Wilken’s decision on whether to certify the lawsuit as a class action that could cover all current and former Division I college athletes. Dumping Electronic Arts is the NCAA’s short-signed, but predictable, reaction to preserve an antiquated system that eliminates free markets for the product, er, athletes.

“This is the evolution of the O’Bannon litigation,” Zola said. “But rather than continue to generate revenue and compensate college athletes, the NCAA has decided to terminate a professional relationship.”

Story Continues →

View Entire Story

© Copyright 2014 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Get Adobe Flash player
You Might Also Like
  • Nathan Walker waits to take the ice during the Capitals' development camp at the Kettler Capitals Iceplex in Arlington on Monday, July 9, 2012. (Ryan M.L. Young/The Washington Times)

    Nathan Walker’s NHL dreams send him around the world

  • Washington Nationals' Anthony Rendon, third from left, smiles as he warms up with his teammates who were were wearing t-shirts in support of him for the All Star game before an interleague baseball game against the Baltimore Orioles at Nationals Park, Tuesday, July 8, 2014, in Washington. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)

    Anthony Rendon not an All-Star, but he’s been Nats’ MVP

  • Baltimore Orioles manager Buck Showalter speaks during a media availability in the dugout before an interleague baseball game against the Washington Nationals at Nationals Park, Monday, July 7, 2014, in Washington. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)

    LOVERRO: Suck-up Buck Showalter needs history lesson

  • Argentina's Maxi Rodriguez, left, celebrates with goalkeeper Sergio Romero after scoring the decisive goal during the World Cup semifinal soccer match between the Netherlands and Argentina at the Itaquerao Stadium in Sao Paulo, Brazil, Wednesday, July 9, 2014. Argentina beat the Netherlands 4-2 in a penalty shootout to reach the World Cup final. (AP Photo/Frank Augstein)

    Argentina beats Dutch in shootout to reach World Cup final

  • Washington Redskins safety Tanard Jackson speaks during a media availability after an NFL football training camp practice at Redskins Park, Friday, Aug. 3, 2012 in Ashburn, Va. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)

    Tanard Jackson suspended indefinitely by NFL — again

  • Celebrities In The News
  • Hall of Fame Inductees, KISS, Paul Stanley, Peter Criss, Gene Simmons, and Ace Frehley speak at the 2014 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Induction Ceremony on Thursday, April, 10, 2014 in New York. (Photo by Charles Sykes/Invision/AP)

    KISS rocker Gene Simmons touts 1 percent life: ‘It’s fantastic’

  • This image from video released by Funny Or Die shows President Obama, left, with actor-comedian Zach Galifianakis during an appearance on "Between Two Ferns," the digital short with a laser focus on reaching people aged 18 to 34. The president urged young people to sign up for the new health care plan through an appearance posted Tuesday, March 11, 2014, on the comic website Funny or Die, bypassing TV talk show titans like Jimmy Fallon or Jimmy Kimmel for an online audience. (AP Photo/Funny Or Die)

    Obama’s ‘Ferns’ interview gets Emmy nod

  • ** FILE ** In this Nov. 12, 2013, file photo, actor Alec Baldwin leaves court in New York. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig, File)

    Alec Baldwin in talks to play Rob Ford-like mayor in new NBC drama