- Strong quake hits Japan, triggering tsunami
- Sniper heaven: Pentagon’s self-guided bullets leave enemies nowhere to hide
- Violent gang taking advantage of immigration crisis, using border as recruiting hub
- Medicaid enrollment continues to soar under Obamacare, administration says
- Michelle Obama to Latinos: ‘We cannot afford to wait on Congress’ for immigration
- White House urges GOP to act ‘urgently’ on $3.7 billion request for illegal immigrants
- Politicians, criminals using ‘right-to-be-forgotten’ law EU courts forced upon Google
- Combat fatigue: elite special forces troops are ‘fraying,’ Gen. Joseph Votel warns
- German foreign minister to meet Kerry to discuss spying claims
- Florida police spokesman tells citizens: ‘Get yourself some firearms’
BOOK REVIEW: ‘Dinner with Churchill’
Question of the Day
DINNER WITH CHURCHILL: POLICY-MAKING AT THE DINNER TABLE
By Cita Stelzer
Pegasus Books, $26.95, 332 pages, illustrated
CATCH THAT TIGER: CHURCHILL'S SECRET ORDER THAT LAUNCHED THE MOST ASTOUNDING AND DANGEROUS MISSION OF WORLD WAR II
By Noel Botham and Bruce Montague
Trafalgar Square/IPG, $24.95, 278 pages, illustrated
An alternative subtitle for Cita Stelzer's delightful account of how Churchill's gusto for food fueled not only his body and soul but also his policymaking might be "A Serious Account of a (Seemingly) Frivolous Subject." For Churchill, satisfying food and a salubrious environment to enjoy it were no mere frivolity. Indeed, you might say that he was dead serious about it, if that seriousness of purpose was not leavened by characteristic Churchillian wit. He loved good food, washed down by fine wines and spirits, and this fueled the formidable energy and inventive resourcefulness that enabled him to be his nation's -- and in some measure, the world's -- savior. Ms. Stelzer's highly informed and consistently insightful study reveals just how much detailed attention he paid to food, not just for himself but for servicemen and civilians in wartime.
Much has been made in books about Churchill of the luxurious consumption he enjoyed at a time when most of his countrymen were subsisting on straitened rations. Ms. Stelzer shows that he did indeed enjoy special privileges, from game shot on the royal estates to citrus fruits hand-delivered by Averell Harriman. But there are also many accounts of wartime meals at the prime minister's table that were characteristic in their skimpiness and make-do qualities of that particular time and place. His longtime aide, Sir John Colville, testified to the efforts of Churchill's wife, Clementine, in providing fare that was a cut above normal governmental offerings, doing her best to adhere, even under such difficult circumstances, to the extremely high level of her prewar standards.
The menus reproduced in Ms. Stelzer's book, along with a photograph of the supremely elegant yet obviously comfortable dining room at their country home, testify to just how Olympian these were. No wonder Mrs. Churchill's efforts to achieve what her husband demanded sometimes drove her close to nervous collapse. Nevertheless, it is clear, in anecdote after anecdote collected by Ms. Stelzer, that everyone in the household, from Clementine Churchill to the cook, knew that providing for the prime minister was not catering to mere whim but actually facilitating his essential contribution.
Ms. Stelzer provides many instances where dinner tables provided the mise-en-scene for diplomatic demarches and strategic planning. Anyone who worked with Churchill knew that he was at his best when well-wined and -dined, his imagination arcing as his rhetoric soared and sparkled. But he could enjoy simpler fare as well, as long as it was well-cooked and savory: his regular planning lunches with Gen. Dwight D. Eisenhower ahead of the Normandy invasion featured a hearty Irish stew. Clearly, he devoted a considerable amount of energy, in wartime as well as in the more leisurely years of peace, to food, and he was marvelously idiosyncratic in his tastes: clear soup, never cream, and only Roquefort or Stilton cheese. However, despite the wealth of gustatory detail she provides, Ms. Stelzer never loses sight of its valuable relationship to the larger picture:
"During the five years I have spent working on this book, I have come to see aspects of his character and personality -- humanity, humor, curiosity, zest and resilience -- that were revealed at the dinner table to an extent not explicitly noted in many of the biographies that rightly concentrate on his enormous impact on world affairs."
For those readers who need a demonstration that Churchill's penchant for detail and hands-on attentiveness were not limited to what was on and around his dinner tables, there is "Catch that Tiger," a gripping account of his determination to capture the Tiger Tank, an important component of the Nazi war machine. The most powerful tank of its time, its 60 tons and formidable range were wreaking havoc on Allied forces, so Churchill personally chose and briefed a young army engineer, Maj. Douglas Lidderdale, exhorting him to "Go catch me a tiger." The success of this daring feat on the battlefields of Tunisia so thrilled Churchill that he and King George VI flew out to inspect the tank captured intact after a fierce firefight. Like Cita Stelzer, the authors of "Catch that Tiger" are not professional historians, but they all know how to tell a story and bring Churchill to life on the page.
Martin Rubin is a writer and critic in Pasadena, Calif.
TWT Video Picks
By Rabbi Shmuley Boteach
Get Breaking Alerts
- Obama calls GOP lawsuit over executive overreach a 'political stunt'
- Pentagon's self-guided bullets leave enemies nowhere to hide
- A 'new Cold War': China's top paper warns of 'slippery slope' towards conflict with U.S.
- Michelle Obama to Latinos: 'We cannot afford to wait on Congress' for immigration
- PRUDEN: 'Dirty Harry' Reids increasing eccentricity
- Florida police spokesman tells citizens: 'Get yourself some firearms'
- Veteran with concealed weapon turns tables on Chicago gunman
- Google Glass-equipped rifles can fire around corners: It's 'mind-blowing when you actually do it'
- Armed militia sets up Texas command center to 'fight for national sovereignty'
- Hamas orders civilians to die in Israeli airstrikes
Recent Letters to the Editor
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: How many boondoggles to break the bank?
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: The problem is unenforced borders
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Where are condolences for Jewish teens' deaths?
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Obama welcomes illegals, ignores Americans
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Obama has no intention of repatriating illegals