- Associated Press - Tuesday, May 7, 2013

PONTE VEDRA BEACH, FLA. (AP) - The Players Championship should consider changing the name of its course to the TPC Mystery.

The reason The Players is talked about as the next best thing to a major is because the field is the strongest and deepest in golf. Until the PGA Tour recently created a spot for the Senior Players Championship winner, anyone who teed it up on the TPC Sawgrass had as good a chance as the next guy.

The mystery is trying to determine whose game best suits the golf course.

The list of winners is impressive, though it doesn’t offer concrete clues except that two-thirds are major champions. More curious is how infrequently some of the game’s best players are even in the mix late Sunday afternoon.

Start with Tiger Woods.

He was runner-up in 2000 to Hal “Be the right club today” Sutton. He won in 2001 with that putt on the island-green 17th that was better than most.

And that’s it.

He tied for 10th one year and finished eighth another. Woods has played 15 times in his career, and he was at the height of his powers for more than half those years, when he could fall out of bed and contend. But at Sawgrass, he’s had only two serious chances at winning.

“There’s no course that less people have worked out than this one,” Geoff Ogilvy said upon leaving Sawgrass last year. “You get one or two chances in your career and you take them. It’s a tournament Tiger has played 15 times and he’s only contended twice. There’s something odd there. Maybe that’s the genius of the golf course. Or maybe that’s the flaw of the golf course.”

But it’s not just Woods.

Phil Mickelson has won 41 times on the PGA Tour, second only to Woods in the last 25 years, with four major championships. He won The Players in 2007, right after switching over to Butch Harmon as his swing coach. And that was the only time he seriously contended at Sawgrass. He tied for third in 2004, but he was five shots behind Adam Scott.

Vijay Singh, with 34 wins and three majors, was runner-up to Woods in 2001. In his 19 other appearances, he never finished higher than eighth. Singh won 17 times from 2003 through 2005. He didn’t record a top 10 at The Players those years _ he missed the cut in 2003 _ and broke 70 twice.

Ernie Els, another four-time major champion in the Hall of Fame, never had a good look at winning The Players.

Those are the “Big Four” of their generation. That’s a collective 72 appearances, two wins and only four chances at winning.

Why?

Story Continues →