We should ask Democratic Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid the same question once posed to Sen. Joseph McCarthy by U.S. Army head counsel Robert N. Welch: “Have you no sense of decency, sir? At long last, have you left no sense of decency?”
Mr. Reid is back in the news for denigrating the peaceful supporters of Nevada rancher Cliven Bundy, a popular critic of the U.S. Bureau of Land Management policy, as “domestic terrorists.”
McCarthy in the 1950s became infamous for smearing his opponents with lurid allegations that he could not prove, while questioning their patriotism. Mr. Reid has brought back to the Senate that exact same McCarthy style of six decades ago — and trumped it.
During the 2012 presidential campaign, Mr. Reid libeled candidate Mitt Romney with the unsubstantiated and later-refuted charge that Mr. Romney was a tax cheat. “The word’s out that [Romney] hasn’t paid any taxes for 10 years,” Mr. Reid said.
Later, when asked for proof, Mr. Reid offered a pathetic rejoinder: “I have had a number of people tell me that.” One wonders how many names were on Mr. Reid’s McCarthyite “tell” list. Were there, as McCarthy used to bluster, 205 names, or perhaps just 57?
When the Koch brothers donated money that was used for political ads — just as liberal political donors George Soros and the Steyer brothers have done — Mr. Reid rushed to the Senate floor to question their patriotism: “These two brothers … are about as un-American as anyone that I can imagine.” The charge of being “un-American” is also vintage McCarthyite slander.
Mr. Reid also has a bad habit of racial bigotry. He once praised then-Sen. Barack Obama because he was, in Mr. Reid’s words, a “light-skinned” black “with no Negro dialect, unless he wanted to have one.”
When Mr. Reid was worried that he would not get enough Hispanic voters to the polls, he condescendingly lectured the Hispanic community: “I don’t know how anyone of Hispanic heritage could be a Republican, OK. Do I need to say more?”
Mr. Reid once singled out for damnation just one Supreme Court justice — Clarence Thomas: “I think that he has been an embarrassment to the Supreme Court.”
During the 2008 presidential campaign, Mr. Reid announced: “I can’t stand John McCain.” Of then-President George W. Bush, he said: “President Bush is a liar.” Mr. Reid claimed that fellow Mormon Mr. Romney had “sullied” his religion.
When Gen. David H. Petraeus brought proof to Congress that the surge in Iraq was beginning to work by late 2007, Mr. Reid declared, “No, I don’t believe him, because it’s not happening.”
He elaborated on that charge by labeling Gen. Petraeus — at the time the senior ground commander of U.S. forces fighting in Iraq — a veritable liar. Mr. Reid alleged that Gen. Petraeus “has made a number of statements over the years that have not proven to be factual.”
When a black and Democratic appointee to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, William Magwood, opposed Mr. Reid on the Yucca Mountain nuclear-waste disposal site controversy, Mr. Reid called him a “first-class rat,” “treacherous, miserable liar,” “[expletive] stirrer,” and “one of the most unethical, prevaricating, incompetent people I’ve ever dealt with.”
Like a pre-reform-era politician, Mr. Reid entered public service relatively poor and will leave it as a multimillionaire. He has granted lucrative favors to casinos and rich investors who hired his sons’ legal firm. While in office, he made considerable profits on private business and real estate deals. Some of those who donated to his campaigns got favorable government treatment.
Mr. Reid recently paid his granddaughter thousands of dollars from his campaign war chest to make jewelry gifts for his donors and friends. Only after a storm of criticism did he reimburse his campaign fund.
So how does Mr. Reid’s reckless career continue with the Senate leader avoiding the sort of congressional censure that finally did in McCarthy? Why is there is no progressive muckraker to take on Mr. Reid the way that Edward R. Murrow once exposed McCarthy?
His lurid, unsubstantiated charges against Mr. Romney were helpful in demonizing the candidate as a rich grandee. His untruths about Gen. Petraeus helped shore up Democrats’ antiwar credentials during the 2008 campaign. Environmentalists did not object to his character assassination of nuclear-power advocate Mr. Magwood.
Mr. Reid’s viciousness also serves as a deterrent. Why tangle with the anything-goes senator when it means endlessly replying to a litany of smears?
Part Tammany Hall-style fixer, part pre-civil rights Democrat and part demagogic Joe McCarthy, Harry Reid is a throwback to a type of American politics better left forgotten.
Victor Davis Hanson is a classicist and historian for the Hoover Institution at Stanford University.