- Obama hosting annual Easter Egg Roll
- Big Bang a big question for most Americans: Poll
- Jimmy Carter’s grandson: People have right to sport Confederate battle flag license plate
- Supreme Court issues no ruling on case challenging N.J. gun law
- Sharyl Attkisson: Media Matters ‘clearly targeted me’
- Sherpas consider boycott after Everest avalanche
- Democrat Rep. Stephen Lynch on Obamacare: ‘We will lose seats’ this November
- Syria to hold presidential election on June 3
- People will be safe at 118th Boston Marathon, Mayor Marty Walsh says
- Boy Scout, 12, killed by rolling tree during troop outing at Washington park
After new Italian murder conviction, Knox’s fate could rest with Kerry
Italy’s supreme court will review the guilty verdict on appeal in coming months, even as the State Department awaits an extradition request from the Italian Embassy in Washington.
If the Italian Supreme Court of Cessation upholds the verdict, Secretary of State John F. Kerry likely will have to decide whether to extradite Ms. Knox or risk the appearance of a U.S. violation of its extradition treaty with Italy, which has been in effect since 1983.
“Secretary Kerry could decide that, given all the alleged due process problems in the prior Italian trial and all the time already spent in detention, that justice is served if the U.S. does not extradite Ms. Knox because she would be subjected to re-prosecution under difficult circumstances,” extradition lawyer Bruce Zagaris told The Washington Times before the verdict was announced.
In a third trial of the American graduate student, an appellate court in Florence, Italy, on Thursday found Ms. Knox and her former boyfriend Raffaelle Sollecito guilty of the murder of British student Meredith Kercher in the university city of Perugia in 2007. Each was sentenced to 28½ years in prison.
Ms. Knox and Mr. Sollecito, both of whom had been held in jail since their 2007 arrests, were convicted in 2009 and sentenced to 30 years in prison. An appellate court in 2011 overturned their convictions, and Ms. Knox returned home to Seattle.
In a statement Thursday, Ms. Knox said called the result an “unjust verdict” that she blamed on an “overzealous and intransigent prosecution,” a “narrow-minded investigation” and coercive interrogation.
“This has gotten out of hand,” she said. “Having been found innocent before, I expected better from the Italian justice system.”
“There isn’t a shred of proof,” Sollecito attorney Luca Maori said. Knox attorney Carlo Dalla Vedova said the court cannot “convict a person because it is probable that she is guilty … it foresees certainty.”
Ms. Knox has received an outpouring of sympathy and support from Americans. The image of the land of the free allowing a foreign power to extradite a young, bright-eyed woman from Seattle to a dark, damp dungeon has not resonated well with some. Support groups have spoken out against extradition ever since Ms. Knox returned home.
In an extradition case, the Justice Department would represent the requesting state — in this case, Italy — before a federal judge or magistrate to sign a Certificate of Extraditibility. But Ms. Knox could not be turned over to Italian authorities without Mr. Kerry’s approval, a decision that may weigh heavy on the conscience of the former prosecutor and father of two daughters.
“The U.S. could take the position that subjecting Ms. Knox to re-prosecution in Italy could violate her constitutional rights as a U.S. citizen,” Mr. Zagaris said. “In circumstances where a requested person has been previously acquitted for the same act or offense in the requesting country, it has been held that there is no constitutional or statutory bar to the U.S. granting extradition. … It is an issue U.S. extradition treaties normally do not cover. Ordinarily, the secretary of state in his or her discretionary authority must deal with this issue.”
Mr. Kerry’s potential conundrum shines a light on the emerging era of “transnational law,” which pits the domestic laws of one country against the citizens of another. In this case, three countries are affected — the U.S., Britain and Italy.
About the Author
Jeffrey Scott Shapiro is a nationally recognized investigative journalist and a former Washington, D.C., prosecutor. He is currently general counsel for MDB International, a D.C.-based international investigations firm, and a legal analyst for The Washington Times. He can be reached at email@example.com.
TWT Video Picks
Women losing coverage under Obamacare, too
- Tactical advantage: Russian military shows off impressive new gear
- USAID documents cite Hillary Clinton in chaos of Afghan aid
- Twitter blocks accounts critical of Turkish government
- Former Ranger breaks silence on Pat Tillman death: I may have killed him
- Scalia to students on high taxes: At a certain point, 'perhaps you should revolt'
- Special Forces' suicide rates hit record levels casualties of 'hard combat'
- Jimmy Carter's grandson: People have right to sport Confederate battle flag license plate
- Feds approve powdered alcohol; 'Palcohol' available later this year
- America is an oligarchy, not a democracy or republic, university study finds
- CURL: Shelly O first lady Michelle Obama comes in last
Top 10 handguns in the U.S.