- The Washington Times - Monday, July 7, 2014

Upon further review — and we knew this beforehand — we’ll never totally eliminate “the human element” that baseball loves and used as a defense in resisting instant replay all these years.

Cutting-edge technology at every conceivable angle still can’t overcome the old-fashioned synapses found in baseball umpires and MLB’s New York-based replay officials.

No matter how many bad calls are made right, the resentment is palpable when incorrect rulings are allowed to stand. Such was the case with Toronto Blue Jays slugger Jose Bautista, who ripped the system Saturday after a 5-1 loss against Oakland.

Bautista couldn’t believe that umpires upheld a call in which Melky Cabrera was called out on a close play at home, although one replay during the two-and-a-half minute delay showed Oakland catcher Derek Norris missing Cabrera’s back with a swipe tag.

“I don’t really know which replay they were looking at, but clearly they must have had a different video feed than the one we had,” Bautista told reporters. “… This whole replay thing has become a joke in my eyes. I think they should just ban it, they should just get rid of it. I don’t really understand the purpose of it, but getting the right call on the field is not the purpose. That’s pretty obvious and evident.”

Chris Marinak sits in front of a bank of television screens during a preview of Major League Baseball's Replay Operations Center, in New York, Wednesday, March 26, 2014.  (AP Photo/Richard Drew)
Chris Marinak sits in front of a bank of television screens during ... more >

Bautista’s emotions got the better of him, partially because the Blue Jays have initiated so many replay challenges at crucial, game-turning junctures and been on the wrong end so often.

According to baseballsavant.com, Toronto and Tampa Bay tied for the most challenges through Sunday at 29 apiece. In MLB this season, the first in which the system has been used, 48 percent of calls have been overturned. The Blue Jays‘ success rate is 31 percent; only the St. Louis Cardinals (15 percent) are worse. Miami (81 percent) leads all of baseball.

Delays can be maddening when umpires linger while TV viewers see clear-cut looks that should make for quick and easy decisions. All of us have experienced Bautista’s incredulity when officials take all that time and then refuse to reverse obvious bad calls.

Nonetheless, growing pains and all, baseball is better off for entering the 21st century and taking advantage of replay technology. A measure of protection from egregious gaffes, such as Dan Denkinger’s infamous blown call in the 1985 World Series, is worth the accompanying interruptions.

Yes, we all make mistakes, including players, umpires, fans and media. Most of us can only apologize and move on. But officials have the opportunity to stop, go back and fix their blunders.

Human nature, like the human element, is still part of the game, though, and officials prefer to keep their colleagues from looking bad whenever possible. That inclination can lead them to expand the definition of “inconclusive evidence.”

In baseball, ties go to the runner … and the umpire.

Bautista suggested something sinister might be at work.

“I don’t know what the right word is, lack of integrity, lack of accountability, or some really good camaraderie that they’re looking after each other or not doing what they’re supposed to be doing,” he said. “Because getting the right call on the field, which is why instant replay was instituted, is not the purpose of what’s happening. The best evidence is what happened [Saturday night].”

He’s wrong. Besides, we can’t use Toronto as the norm.

Story Continues →