Tillman’s first-inning ERA ballooned to 9.90 after he gave up four to begin the game then followed it up by giving up four more in the second without recording an out.
Not exactly the follow-up he was expecting after tossing a shutout in his previous start against Kansas City.
“Coming off a good one, you’d like to carry it over and get into rhythm here,” Tillman said. “It was tough. I battled and tried to make adjustments, but they just weren’t coming to me.”
Tillman gave up eight runs, six earned, in one-plus inning, walking three and striking out one while his overall ERA sailed from 3.34 to 4.21.
“Chris has spoiled us at a high level pitching,” Baltimore manager Buck Showalter said. “Tonight was just a tough night for him. He’s struggled before early and gotten back in sync and gave us some strong innings, but it just never really came to him tonight.”
Nelson Cruz hit his 14th homer of the season and drove in three runs for the Orioles, who rallied to tie the game at 8 in the top of the seventh before reliever Ryan Webb (2-1) gave it back in the bottom of the inning on Tony Sanchez’s RBI-single.
“You had two early exits from starters and it became a game out of the bullpen and they pushed one across there late,” Showalter said. “But our guys, we had a couple opportunities to score some more, but I can’t fault the offense.”
Andrew McCutchen went 3 for 4 with an RBI and his first two extra-base hits in more than two weeks for Pittsburgh, which won for only the third time in its past nine games. Starling Marte and Ike Davis had three hits and two RBIs apiece for the Pirates.
Bryan Morris (4-0) earned the victory after failing to protect an 8-6 lead. Mark Melancon worked a perfect ninth for his seventh save.
Pittsburgh began the night eight games under .500 in part because of a struggling starting staff that has hardly looked like the group that led the team to the postseason last fall.
Things didn’t get much better, but the bullpen briefly recaptured its touch.
Reliever Vin Mazzaro’s steady hand out of the bullpen played in stark contrast to the mess made by Pittsburgh starter Wandy Rodriguez.