- The Washington Times - Wednesday, March 22, 2000

ATLANTIC CITY, N.J. Miss America is getting skinnier and skinnier.
Using the heights and weights from most of the winners in the pageant's 78-year history, nutrition experts from the Johns Hopkins School of Public Health concluded that many are in the undernourished range.
The research was published in today's Journal of the American Medical Association.
Dr. Benjamin Caballero, director of the Center for Human Nutrition at Johns Hopkins, said pageant officials should screen out contestants who are too skinny to "promote a message of healthiness."
"The actual influence of pageant competitions on young women's decisions about diet and lifestyle is not well-documented, but it is likely to have a strong, if indirect, effect," he wrote.
The researchers used the height and weight figures to calculate a measure, called body mass index (BMI), and concluded that it has generally fallen over the years. BMI is derived by multiplying one's weight in pounds by 704.5 and dividing that number by the square of height in inches.
In the 1920s, contestants had BMIs in the range now considered normal, which is 20 to 25, the researchers said. But an increasing number of winners since then have had BMIs under 18.5, which is the World Health Organization's standard for undernutrition.
The highest index was 22.4 for Miss America 1941, Rosemary LaPlanche; the lowest, 16.9, for Miss America 1986 Susan Akin.
The pageant was not held from 1927 to 1933, and vital statistics were not available for some of the years since 1990, when the pageant stopped listing contestants' heights and weights.
The medical journal did not publish the heights and weights of the winners.
The lightest Miss America, according to the Press of Atlantic City newspaper archives, was also the first 1921's Margaret Gorman, who weighed 108 pounds. The heaviest was Miss America 1952 Colleen Kay Hutchins, who weighed 143.
Pageant winners, like the rest of the U.S. population, have gotten progressively taller. But that doesn't explain the thinning of Miss America, the researchers said. Pageant winners' height increased less than 2 percent, but body weight decreased 12 percent.
However, Robert M. Renneisen Jr., chief executive of the Miss America Organization, said recent winners have had some of the highest body mass readings, a reflection of pageant officials' emphasizing brains over beauty.
The swimsuit competition counts for only 10 percent of the total score, he said.
"We long ago made the change from more superficial to more substantial criteria," Mr. Renneisen said. "We're seeing that, not only in the caliber of the young women competing but the very data they show here, which shows that from 1986, even physically, the kind of person is changing."
One eating-disorders expert said the report substantiates what he has suspected all along.
"Beauty pageants, like the rest of our media-driven culture, give young women in particular a message, over and over again, that it's exceedingly important to be thin to be considered successful and attractive," said Dr. Harry Brandt, director of the Center for Eating Disorders at St. Joseph Medical Center in Towson, Md.

Sign up for Daily Newsletters

Manage Newsletters

Copyright © 2020 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.


Click to Read More and View Comments

Click to Hide