- The Washington Times - Monday, July 23, 2001

BONN, Germany Negotiators from 178 nations rescued the 1997 Kyoto Protocol after 48 hours of marathon talks ending today, leaving the United States isolated as the rest of the world embraced the first binding treaty on combating global warming.
Despite appeals from his closest allies at a summit in Italy this weekend, President Bush refused to reconsider his rejection of the pact, which he deems harmful to the U.S. economy.
European envoys said the treaty would be stronger with U.S. participation, but that Washington would be welcome to join at any time.
“Almost every single country stayed in the protocol,'' Olivier Deleuze, the chief European Union negotiator, said. “There was one that said the Kyoto Protocol was flawed. Do you see the Kyoto Protocol flawed?''
Paula Dobriansky, the head of the U.S. delegation, noted the deal will not require the United States to fund any part of the treaty one of Washington's chief concerns.
“Although the United States does not intend to ratify that agreement, we have not sought to stop others from moving ahead, so long as legitimate U.S. interests were protected,'' she said. “This does not change our view the Kyoto Protocol is not sound policy.''
Ms. Dobriansky drew boos from the gallery when she said the Bush administration was committed to tackling climate change. “We will not abdicate our responsibility,'' she said.
As news of the deal swept through the delegations, hundreds of negotiators waiting in the convention hall lobby hugged each other in joy. Two hours later, conference chairman Jan Pronk signaled adoption of the draft with a rap of a gavel before the full conference.
Mr. Pronk, wearing a fresh suit after working through two nights, was greeted by a standing ovation.
“It is very important to show that global developments can be met and addressed by globally responsible decision-making,'' Mr. Pronk, the Dutch environment minister, said.
The breakthrough in talks on setting rules for implementation of the Kyoto Protocol came after nations agreed to drop legally binding sanctions for violators of the treaty, opposed by Japan.
During talks that began at the expert level last Monday, delegates negotiated four crucial areas: financing, emission credits for forests soaking up carbon dioxide, mechanisms for offsetting pollution reduction targets as well as sanctions.
Addressing funding concerns by developing nations trying to improve emissions controls so they can one day join the treaty, the European Union announced a $410 million fund.
Envoys admitted the deal fell short of tight rules they initially sought.
“I prefer an imperfect agreement that is living to an imperfect agreement that doesn't exist,'' Mr. Deleuze said.
The deal clears the way for nations to continue the process of ratifying the protocol, which delegates hope to achieve in 2002, the 10th anniversary of the Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro. The treaty must be ratified by 55 nations responsible for more than half of global green gas emissions to take force. Some 30 nations have ratified the pact to date.
Threatened with the second breakdown of negotiations in eight months, Mr. Pronk urged the yawning delegates late Sunday to redouble their efforts and to contact their capitals for guidance.
He appealed to them not to offer new amendments, which would lead to sure collapse.
“This is a good text. It is a balanced text,'' Mr. Pronk said.
Most delegations agreed last night to accept without any changes Mr. Pronk's compromise proposal on rules governing the protocol. But Japan held fast to its refusal to accept the accord's enforcement clause.
Pronk said holdout countries, including developing countries seeking funding guarantees, carried enough weight to block ratification of the accord, which aims to curb the emissions of greenhouse gases blamed for global warming.
The deadlock forced the high-level delegates to continue a long series of consultations as minister after minister missed flights home from the conference, originally scheduled to end last night.
The climate talks were resumed in Bonn after failing once before when a conference last November in The Hague, Netherlands, collapsed in a last-minute dispute between the United States and the Europeans.
That convention was held while ballots were still being counted in the U.S. election that brought Mr. Bush to office. He renounced the Kyoto pact three months later.
In a major concession by the EU, the accord allows countries to offset their obligations to reduce industrial pollution by counting the proper management of forests and farmlands that absorb carbon dioxide, known as carbon “sinks.''
Environmental groups said the heavy allowance for sinks effectively reduced the commitment in the Kyoto accord to cut emissions by 5.2 percent from their 1990 levels. In fact, the reduction would be closer to 1.8 percent, said the World Wildlife Fund for Nature.

LOAD COMMENTS ()

 

Click to Read More

Click to Hide