- The Washington Times - Wednesday, July 25, 2001

China yesterday sentenced two U.S. residents, including American University scholar Gao Zhan, to 10 years in prison for espionage, roiling relations just two days before a visit to Beijing by Secretary of State Colin L. Powell.
Later, China deported an American business professor who had been convicted 10 days earlier, the Foreign Ministry announced early today.
Li Shaomin, a Chinese-born naturalized American citizen was expelled to the United States, the ministry said in a brief written statement.
The Associated Press, quoting a U.S. official in Beijing, reported that Mr. Li was being flown to San Francisco.
Mr. Li's expulsion had been expected since he had been ordered out of the country following his July 14 conviction.
However, the sentencing of Mrs. Gao and a second U.S. based academic, Qin Guangguang, to lengthy prison terms came as a double blow to U.S.-China relations. It came one a day before Mr. Powell was to meet Chinese Foreign Minister Tang Jiaxuan in Hanoi before traveling on to Beijing.
"We are dismayed by the outcome," said a spokesman for Mr. Powell, who is to attend a meeting today of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations. "We are concerned by the lack of transparency."
U.S. officials were not permitted to attend the trial of Mrs. Gao, 39, whose husband and son live in the Washington area. They also were not permitted to attend the trial of a second scholar with U.S. permanent resident status, Qin Guangguang, who also received a 10-year sentence. Mr. Qin reportedly taught at U.S. universities and worked for a U.S. medical group in Beijing.
A third person, Chinese national Qu Wei, was sentenced to 13 years yesterday for providing documents to Mrs. Gao.
A series of recent arrests of U.S. based scholars has alarmed the academic world because their activities, such as collecting Chinese newspaper and magazine articles, had been considered routine.
A U.S. official who closely monitors China said it was believed within the U.S. government that one or both of the American residents sentenced yesterday would be released as a gesture of good will before or during Mr. Powell's visit.
"You have to admire China's cunning and deception" in arresting scholars such as Mrs. Gao and then releasing them as gestures of good will, said the official, who spoke on the condition of anonymity.
"These cases are a clever way to raise the bar. They say that if you even so much as Xerox unclassified documents on Taiwan, it's espionage. They are crushing the human rights movement, and anyone with U.S. connections who would try to discuss Taiwan policy can be jailed."
The Powell spokesman said the United States was disappointed at being barred from Mrs. Gao's trial, which lasted less than three hours. Members of Mrs. Gao's family were also refused permission to attend.
The spokesman said Mr. Powell would raise the case in his meeting with Mr. Tang in Hanoi today and with Chinese officials in Beijing the following day.
Supporters and lawyers for Mrs. Gao said at a Washington news conference that the evidence against her consisted of photocopies of publications and writings about Taiwan and women's rights. None was marked "classified," and all are readily available throughout the free world, said Sen. George F. Allen, Virginia Republican.
Lawyer Bai Xuebiao, who represented Mrs. Gao at her trial, said that his client was allowed to speak during the proceedings, but that she was "in very low spirits" after being sentenced. She has 10 days to appeal the verdict.
"She believed the length of her sentence was too long," said Mr. Bai.
Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Sun Yuxi said in Hanoi: "We have irrefutable evidence that Gao Zhan worked for Taiwan espionage agencies and received funds from them. Moreover, she openly admitted her crimes."
But Mr. Bai said his client "persists in believing her actions do not constitute espionage."
In Washington, American University officials, Mr. Allen and leaders of the Lutheran Church condemned the ruling, saying it violated the basic human right to free expression.
"Justice has not been done," said Mr. Allen. The Chinese "have a tremendous fear of academics."
Mrs. Gao's husband, Xue Donghua, said that in light of the evidence the conviction for spying did not "make any sense."
In earlier remarks on Reuters television, he said the decision was politically motivated and "totally outrageous."
Both he and their son, Andrew, 5, were also detained by Chinese authorities in February. They were later released while Mrs. Gao was held for trial.
Mr. Xue also said his wife has an irregular heartbeat and stomach problems that worsen when she is under stress. Her attorneys say her health has deteriorated since she was imprisoned 51/2 months ago.
"I certainly don't want her to die in custody, which is unacceptable," Mr. Xue, a computer analyst living in McLean, said in the Reuters interview.
China has previously released dissidents or accused spies for medical treatment.
The decision to order Mr. Li's deportation, which came immediately after his conviction, was believed to be linked to the fact that he was a U.S. citizen, although of Chinese descent.
The Senate and House of Representatives have bills under consideration that would bestow U.S. citizenship on Mrs. Gao.
Mr. Allen said she had been preparing already and "has passed all requirements, except for one — raising her hand and taking the oath of allegiance."
A total of five scholars with American connections have been arrested for spying in China in the past year. The others are Wu Jianming, also a U.S. citizen, and permanent U.S. residents Liu Yaping and Teng Chunyan.
The U.S. official who monitors China said the arrests were part of a larger Chinese offensive aimed at countering the State Department's human rights criticism of Chinese repression.
China has already neutralized U.S. efforts to win condemnation of China in the U.N. Human Rights Commission and accused the United States of human rights abuses against American Indians and blacks, he said.

Sign up for Daily Newsletters

Copyright © 2019 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

The Washington Times Comment Policy

The Washington Times welcomes your comments on Spot.im, our third-party provider. Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.


Click to Read More and View Comments

Click to Hide