- The Washington Times - Tuesday, June 19, 2001

Advocates for student prayer in public schools won two cases and lost one at the Supreme Court yesterday, further muddling the national patchwork of rules.
Justices refused to block an Alabama law allowing student-led prayer at extracurricular gatherings, cleared the way for the Louisiana Christian Coalition to meet in school facilities also open to secular groups, and refused to intervene in a decision barring a New Jersey first-grader from reading a Bible story to classmates.
The three unrelated school-prayer decisions were among hundreds of actions announced as the court cleared the way for summer recess, with 10 decisions left to announce next week from the term that began in October.
About half of those cases on which arguments were heard involve immigration issues. The court also is wrestling with the rights of a property owner to develop wetlands in Rhode Island, financial interests of free-lance writers whose published material is redistributed electronically, and whether the federal government may limit spending by political parties.
In other action yesterday, the court:
Made it far more difficult to win "excessive force" lawsuits against police officers. The justices were unanimous in ruling that the level of force used to quell a protest did not determine if an officer had qualified immunity from being sued, and voted 8-1 that military police need not face trial for the 1994 arrest of animal rights protester Elliot Katz, who was pushed into a van at the San Francisco Presidio during a speech by Vice President Al Gore.
Closed a loophole in the time limit for state prisoners to challenge convictions in federal courts, ruling 7-2 in a New York robbery case that criminals may not exceed the one-year limit on raising issues in federal court not raised in state appeals.
Agreed to decide next term the limits on copycat products that exploit alterations in patent applications, using provisions not included in later versions of the application. The case was brought by Festo Corp. of New York, which charged that a Japanese competitor had copied a trademarked machine design.
The prayer cases came on the heels of last weeks 6-3 ruling allowing the Good News Club for elementary school children in upstate Milford, N.Y., to attend after-school prayer meetings in classrooms also made available to secular groups.
The American Center for Law and Justice said the Good News Club decision "sends a strong message" and will be invoked under yesterdays order to allow the Christian Coalition to use public schools in St. Tammany Parish, the Louisiana equivalent of a county.
"What the Supreme Court has done is said that the lower court got it wrong, that our client … should not be subject to discriminatory treatment by a school district," said Stuart J. Roth, an ACLJ attorney in the case.
Unlike the Louisiana appeal, in which the court directed lower courts on how to dispose of the case, the Alabama and New Jersey cases were issued without comment and had no application as binding precedent beyond those regions.
The Medford, N.J., case ended a five-year fight over whether public school teacher Grace Oliva should have barred first-grader Zachary Hood from reading classmates a story from "The Beginners Bible."
"If anything may be said regarding the 'right to read 'The Beginners Bible to the classmates of petitioners son, it is that this right was not at all clearly established at the time of the incident. If anything, the contrary is true," attorneys for the school board argued.
Miss Oliva rewarded reading skills by permitting winners to read favorite short and simple stories to classmates. Zachary chose a story called "A Big Family," based on estranged Old Testament brothers Jacob and Esau. Court records indicate the text in "The Beginners Bible" was not overtly religious, but the teacher decided it was inappropriate for the class and had a private reading.
The principal supported the teacher on the grounds that reading the story would be "the equivalent of praying."
Aided by the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, the boys mother, Carol Hood, sued to change the policy and receive money for discrimination.
The Alabama decision leaves in force a 1993 state law allowing elementary and high school students to participate in group prayers at such school functions as football games, student assemblies or graduations. Last year, the court upheld a ban on such prayer in Texas schools. The Alabama law says any prayer must be nonsectarian and that students cannot proselytize.
Aided by the American Civil Liberties Union, DeKalb County high school Vice Principal Michael Chandler and his son sued to overturn the law.

Sign up for Daily Newsletters

Copyright © 2019 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

The Washington Times Comment Policy

The Washington Times welcomes your comments on Spot.im, our third-party provider. Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.


Click to Read More and View Comments

Click to Hide