- The Washington Times - Friday, November 1, 2002

Doug Ecklund totes up 11 months of job searching with these figures: about 1,000 resumes sent via e-mail, just two interviews in person, one over the telephone, and zero offers.
But if the lack of success is discouraging, what irritates the systems analyst is the overall dearth of return communication. Only about 50 of his resumes drew responses; the rest netted nothing at all.
"We grew up in that era of where a courtesy was nice," said Mr. Ecklund, of Huntley, Ill. "Most [recruiters and employers], if they do respond, will send you back an automated response. 'We got your resume, thank you for your letter, by the way, check out our Web site.' That's it."
Mr. Ecklund's frustration is all too familiar to the ranks of job hunters, now swollen by an economic downturn and waves of layoffs. More employers, deluged with resumes and increasingly leaving it to computers to sort through them all, are abandoning the courtesy letter and the polite callback as quaint but outdated customs.
When the obituary is written for the courtesy note, technology will be listed as the cause of death. Many companies now use computerized resume-management systems to scan, store and respond automatically to inquiries. Internet job boards like Monster.com and Hotjobs.com let job seekers spot and instantaneously reply to dozens of listings in just a few minutes.
But the decline of the courtesy note is about people as well as machines. The economic downturn has left many more people searching for work, and corporate cutbacks have included reductions in the very personnel and recruiting departments charged with handling the tide of resumes and cover letters.
"This is how rude the workplace has gotten," said Robin Ryan, a Seattle-based career counselor, who blames the lack of responses on corporate cost-cutting and the tide of applicants.
"You come in for an interview and they just leave you hanging. You usually have to call them back," she said. For many companies, "I really think it's the 37 cents. It's gotten so expensive that they choose not to do it."
But some employers, who say they do try to respond to all inquiries, point out they are swimming in resumes.
Abbott Laboratories, for example, says its personnel department has received about 200,000 resumes so far this year, roughly double the number for all of 2001. Microsoft Corp. says it is getting 45,000 resumes each month, up from about 20,000 a month two years ago and 30,000 a month last year.
Both companies say they have policies of replying to all resumes with at least a computer-automated response sent via e-mail.
"Every person who enters a resume gets some kind of a response," said Melissa Brotz, an Abbott spokeswoman. It doesn't always work that way at other companies, though.
"Hopefully companies have a system set in place to deal with incoming resumes," said Kristin Bowl of the Society for Human Resource Management, an industry group for personnel officers. "However, some companies make a policy that they don't respond to resumes that come in if they haven't posted a position They get so many of those they just can't keep up with the volume."
Even when the boom economy had employers eager to hire, the courtesy letter was hardly a given. Just 45 percent of companies surveyed in 1999 by SHRM said they responded in writing to unsolicited resumes and 14 percent said such resumes went into the trash. A quarter of the companies surveyed said they scanned incoming resumes into a computer.
But the role of computers in processing and responding to resumes has increased substantially since then, analysts say. That is particularly true at large companies, many of which now direct applicants to apply via the Internet.
"What happens is any resume that comes in over the Web automatically gets tucked into a human resource management system and never gets a human eye," said Peter Weddle, author of "Weddle's Job Seeker's Guide to Employment Web Sites."
Recruiters then use key words say "bookkeeping" or "marketing" to search the database for candidates who may fit their hiring requirements. Resumes that don't include the key words may never get even a first look.
The sea of applications has deepened because many job seekers have turned into what Mr. Weddle calls "graffiti applicants" sending out multiple electronic cover letters and resumes to employers, frequently for jobs they are not qualified to do.
"Everybody can just press 'send,' 'send,' 'send,'" said Kate Wendleton, president of the Five O'Clock Club, a New York career counseling firm. "You have to assume you're not going to get called in. You have to find some other way in."
That advice is repeated as gospel by career counselors and the people they advise. Job seekers increasingly assume that they will not hear anything from many employers, even in the form of computer-generated "thank you" notes, without a personal connection, said Kathy Andre of the Career Place, a publicly funded employment office in Woburn, Mass.
Tracy Vachon, a Westford, Mass., marketing executive who lost her job last year, says she tries to play the game both ways, posting her resume to corporate Web sites mostly as a formality even as she tries to make connections inside companies to make sure her application gains an audience beyond the computer.
Many job seekers, frustrated that their resumes are being swallowed in a black hole, are flocking to networking sessions, looking for someone who has a friend who knows a manager who might be hiring.
At the Barrington, Ill., Career Center, a single Tuesday morning networking meeting used to draw about 15 people. But on a recent Tuesday, back-to-back sessions drew a combined 104 job seekers.
Networking has its own frustrations. Mr. Ecklund says when he has called people inside his former company on behalf of friends looking for work, he has been told five times they should just send their resumes to the company Web site.
In an environment where employers can afford to be picky and take their time, even an interview doesn't guarantee communication.
Bob Creech, an unemployed credit manager from Arlington Heights, Ill., said he immediately sent "thank you" notes to the people he had met during an interview six weeks ago.
"I never heard 'boo' back from them, not even on e-mail," Mr. Creech said. "I think the trail's gone cold by now."

Copyright © 2019 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

The Washington Times Comment Policy

The Washington Times welcomes your comments on Spot.im, our third-party provider. Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.


Click to Read More and View Comments

Click to Hide