- The Washington Times - Tuesday, February 18, 2003

A cadre of military brass from past administrations yesterday joined forces to advise the Supreme Court that universities require racial preferences to assure enough minority officers to command the increasingly diverse fighting force.
"The progress the military has made thus far must be protected and must continue. An alternative that does not preserve both diversity and selectivity is no alternative at all," said the brief, whose 29 signers include two Clinton administration secretaries of defense and three of the last four chairmen of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.
"Full integration and other policies combating discrimination are essential to good order, combat readiness and military effectiveness," said former Army Undersecretary Joe R. Reeder, the Washington lawyer who prepared the legal brief with co-counsel Carter Phillips.
"We are looking forward to making sure we can have future Colin Powells," said retired Adm. Dennis Blair, the Navy's former Pacific commander.
That brief is but one of dozens expected to be filed today in the high-court challenge to affirmative-action programs that help lesser-qualified blacks, Hispanics and American Indians win admission to the University of Michigan. The case will be argued April 1.
Most of the 20 briefs already on file back white students who challenged the plans. Those include one by the Bush administration that calls the university plan disguised quotas, so clearly unconstitutional that the justices need not decide if race ever can be a factor.
Michigan officials predict the filings by today's deadline may exceed the record for amicus curiae briefs. The 1978 University of California v. Bakke affirmative-action case set a record with 54 briefs, but was eclipsed in 1989 when 78 briefs were filed in an abortion case, Webster v. Reproductive Health Services. The runner-up is the 1997 assisted-suicide case, in which 60 friend-of-the-court briefs were filed.
University of Michigan President Mary Sue Coleman also emphasized the potential impact on military readiness as she urged justices yesterday "not to turn back the clock" by banning use of racial factors.
"The Army, the Navy, the Air Force, and the Marines rely on the ability to take race into account in our ROTC programs and at their highly selective service academies," Mrs. Coleman said in addressing the American Council on Education meeting at the Marriott Wardman Park Hotel. She spoke via satellite from Ann Arbor, Mich., her university's seat, because of the snowstorm.
"We simply cannot handcuff our country's major institutions in their efforts to seek both quality and diversity," she said.
A Pentagon spokesman would not comment on the Michigan lawsuit but said, "The Department of Defense has been at the forefront of providing equal opportunity in the workplace and in education and will continue to do so."
Mr. Reeder said the brief-signers do not espouse quotas or believe that minorities must be led only by officers of their own race.
"Absolutely not. There's no implication whatever," said the former Airborne officer. "However, that serviceman needs to know that those officers exist and to the extent that he or she delivers excellence they have the chance to rise and the service is fair and recognizes merit."
He said progress has been made in desegregating military academies since his 1970 graduation from West Point, when seven blacks were in his 750-member graduating class. Currently, he said, about 300 of 4,000 West Point cadets are black.
"The numbers do not match society. They have not gotten to parity," he said of an officer corps that is 19 percent minority, while enlisted ranks are 40 percent so. Unlike the Michigan program, West Point and other federal service academies do not accept substandard applicants, but help prospects attend prep schools to hone skills.
"If someone is not highly qualified, you're not going to make it," he said.
Among other signatories of Mr. Reeder's brief are former Defense Secretaries William Cohen and William Perry, former Joint Chiefs of Staff Chairmen Gen. Hugh Shelton, Gen. John Shalikashvili and Adm. William J. Crowe; Gens. Norman Schwarzkopf and Wesley K. Clark, and presidential candidate Sen. John Kerry, Massachusetts Democrat, a Vietnam War veteran.
Mr. Reeder said Mr. Powell a former general and JCS chairman from 1989 to 1993, and now secretary of state is a supporter of affirmative action, but was not asked to sign the brief because it would have been improper for him to do so.

Sign up for Daily Newsletters

Manage Newsletters

Copyright © 2019 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.


Click to Read More and View Comments

Click to Hide