- The Washington Times - Friday, January 10, 2003

President Bush has proposed a $630 billion tax cut to help pull the economy out if its two-year, bear market rut. In releasing the plan, Mr. Bush seemed to be announcing to the nation: When it comes to tax cuts to energize the economy, size does matter.
He's right. This bold plan 5 times larger than the Democratic alternative is exactly the right fiscal medicine at the right time. Its beneficiaries will be workers, investors, states, and cities all of which are front-line victims of anemic economic growth rates.
The centerpiece of the president's plan is elimination of the double taxation of dividends. Currently, dividend income is taxed as corporate income to the business, and then as personal income to the individual receiving the dividend. This can result in effective tax rates on dividends as high as 70 percent. These punitive tax rates, in turn, reduce stock values, capital investment, and savings.
John Rutledge, a respected Wall Street economist and a former Reagan administration economist, estimates elimination of the dividend tax could cause stock values to rise by as much as 10 percent, which is good news for the 85 million American shareholders. Gary Robbins, of Fiscal Associates, says a dividend tax cut will increase gross domestic product by at least $5 for every $1 of reduced tax receipts. Even the Democratic critics of the president's plan unwittingly acknowledged the value of this plan by conceding that the plan would stimulate the stock market. What is wrong with a plan that raises the wealth holdings and retirement incomes of American stockholders, who now comprise almost half of all U.S. households?
The other major feature of the Bush tax stimulus plan is to fast forward the tax cuts from the president's 2001 plan. This, too, makes good economic sense.
The phased in tax cuts in the 2001 tax plan were always of questionable economic benefit. Would you go to the store today to buy a product if the store advertised that tomorrow the price will be marked down by another 20 percent? Delayed tax cuts, delay economic activity and often have exactly the opposite impact as hoped. They destimulate the economy.
President Bush would accelerate his earlier tax cut. A majority of House and Senate members voted for the tax cut two years ago. Why not provide the full economic bang of the tax cut now, when the economy most desperately needs a shot of steroids? Cutting the highest income tax rates raises is especially stimulative because roughly 2 out of every 3 Americans paying the highest tax rates are small business owners. They are the wealth and job producers in our economy.
One reason the U.S. economy is ailing is that business investment has fallen dramatically. Simultaneously, the U.S. venture capital industry, which provides the seed corn for new developing 21st-century companies, is almost entirely dormant today. Why the skittishness? Investors don't see the profit opportunities in new ventures. Costs are too high for new businesses thanks to government meddling; payoffs are too meager thanks to excessive taxes on capital investment i.e. the capital-gains tax and the dividends tax.
The objective of this plan is to replicate the tax cut successes of Presidents Reagan and Kennedy. It was JFK who said, "It is a paradoxical truth that when tax rates are too high the economy will never produce enough jobs or enough revenues to balance the budget." Deficit hawks in both parties will no doubt squeal that this tax plan is unaffordable and will run up the national debt. They are wrong. What Kennedy and Mr. Reagan and now George W. Bush understand clearly is that it is the absence of economic growth that causes runaway budget deficits.
So let the class-warfare Democrats embrace small and impotent policy changes changes that increasingly sophisticated investor-class voters will immediately identify as fraudulent. The obstructionist Democrats have announced they intend to fight against President Bush's genuine Republican growth package and to wage all-out class-envy warfare. President Bush has 90 million investor-class Americans on his side who realize tax rate cuts mean higher stock values and greater retirement security.
Republicans must not shrink from the battle. Bring on the fight.

Stephen Moore is president of the Club for Growth and a senior fellow at the Cato Institute.

LOAD COMMENTS ()

 

Click to Read More

Click to Hide