- The Washington Times - Tuesday, January 28, 2003

The Daschle-Democrats are on the war path on the economy. They are crassly rooting against a recovery, and they are working like armies of wood ants behind the scenes to erode any and all of President Bush's economic initiatives including most prominently his bold tax cut plan. Anything that would hasten an economic growth revival before the 2002 elections, they reflexively oppose.
Now we will find out whether that opposition also applies to any person who wishes to spur faster economic growth. Today, President Bush's Treasury secretary nominee John Snow, the former chief executive officer of CSX Railroad, goes before the Senate for confirmation hearings. Some Senate Democrats have been threatening to convert these hearings into an ugly and coordinated campaign of character assassination against Mr. Snow. Conservatives have become all too familiar with the brutish politics of personal destruction that the Senate Democrats are capable of with regards to many of President Bush's judicial nominees.
It's high time that conservatives in the Senate fight back if those tactics are brought to bear against Mr. Snow who is an exceptional choice for the job.
I must confess I know John Snow personally, like him very much, and have an unqualified admiration for his political views and his supply-side instincts. We met when we both served on the Kemp Commission on Tax Reform. What became clear during those months is that Mr. Snow wants what the vast majority of Americans want: a radically simplified, single-rate tax system that clears away the barriers to growth in the IRS tax code, eliminates unfair subsidies, flattens tax rates, and doesn't require hoards of accountants, lawyers, and Valium pills to figure out tax liabilities.
Jack Kemp tells me John Snow is "thoroughly on the supply side when it comes to the case for lower tax rates." He is also a free trader and an inflation hawk. There's very little in this man's record not to like from a policy standpoint.
John Snow has a sterling record of accomplishment as a railroad executive. When he became CEO of CSX he helped turn this once-moribund railroad into a profitable enterprise though it certainly has gone through through rough patches. His stewardship has created wealth for shareholders and tens of thousands of jobs for rail workers.
Any case against Mr. Snow's professional capabilities will be weakened considerably, given that several unions have written letters to President Bush commending him for choosing Mr. Snow for the Treasury secretary slot. Byron Boyd, the president of the United Transportation Union writes: "The thoughtful and successful approaches that CSX has taken on safety and labor relations are but two examples of John's ability. … I urge the Senate to confirm him expeditiously."
In this post-Enron political environment where every CEO is a member of a suspect class, the Democrats are expected to attack Mr. Snow for receiving multimillion-dollar bonuses and loans. There is no smoking gun here. Mr. Snow's compensation packages were in no way out of line with the incentives given to CEOs of similarly-sized companies.
To get top talent like John Snow firms must pay top dollar. This is the economic reality of the marketplace. Why should making money for successfully running a company be invalid? And if it is, how in the world was Robert Rubin ever confirmed as Treasury secretary? Mr. Rubin made far more money running Goldman Sachs than Mr. Snow has. So did Sen. John Corzine, New Jersey Democrat, also a partner at Goldman.
Why is making money only a crime when the wealth creator is a Republican?
Democrats will also certainly use the Snow confirmation hearings as their first opportunity to savage the president's economic plan in a public forum. That's fair game. Mr. Snow must not back off. He, and the Senate Republicans must assault the assaulters. The Republicans should recite the history of supply-side tax reduction successes under John F. Kennedy and Mr. Reagan and even Mr. Clinton, when he signed the capital-gains tax cut in 1997.
They should ridicule the Democratic plan, which stimulates nothing but growth in government and provides about one-fifth the tax relief for Americans than the president's plan does.
The Republicans in the Senate but most importantly, Mr. Snow himself should not suffer fools gladly. If the Democrats attack the tax-cut plan for being "fiscally irresponsible," Mr. Snow should ask his accusers why they vote to continually pad spending bills with billions of dollars of pork and multibillion-dollar program expansions with more debt spending as they did last week with a $390 billion appropriations bill. If they attack Mr. Snow's business acumen, he should point out that almost none of these prosecutors have ever run a business themselves, or met a payroll themselves, that wasn't paid for with taxpayer dollars.
With the economy showing further signs of weakness in recent weeks (fourth-quarter 2002 GDP growth is now estimated at an anemic rate of 1 percent), the country desperately needs the president's economic growth and jobs tax cut.
What the president's tax plan needs is dogged, determined, and compelling defenders. This is Mr. Snow's first big test. My bet is that he will pass with fling colors much to the disappointment of the Daschle-Democrats.

Stephen Moore is president of the Club for Growth.

Copyright © 2019 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

The Washington Times Comment Policy

The Washington Times welcomes your comments on Spot.im, our third-party provider. Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.


Click to Read More and View Comments

Click to Hide