- The Washington Times - Tuesday, July 1, 2003

WACO, Texas — A police informant told authorities that missing Baylor basketball player Patrick Dennehy was shot in the head with a 9 mm handgun by a former teammate from Maryland’s Eastern Shore after the two had an argument, according to court documents released yesterday.

The teammate and former roommate, Carlton Dotson, told a cousin he got in an argument with Dennehy while they were shooting guns in the Waco area and that Dennehy pointed a gun at Dotson as if to shoot him, the informant said.

But Dotson instead shot Dennehy in the head with the pistol, the informant said. Dotson said he then drove home to Hurlock, Md., and got rid of the guns along the way, the informant said.

The search warrant affidavit released yesterday was filed June 23 in McLennan County by Waco police detective Bob Fuller. According to the Waco Tribune-Herald, police obtained the warrant to analyze Dennehy’s computer, thinking reported threats against Dennehy might be reflected in his e-mails, Fuller wrote in the affidavit. He said he thinks there is probable cause to believe the computer’s disk drive contains “evidence of murder.”

District Attorney John Segrest declined to comment yesterday, referring questions to Waco police. Fuller did not return a phone call to the Associated Press yesterday. A message left on an answering machine at a number listed for Dotson’s guardians in Maryland was not immediately returned.

Waco Police Chief Alberto Melis said no body had been found and no arrests have been made, and he would not elaborate on any evidence. Waco police spokesman Steven Anderson has said authorities believe “potential suspects” include fellow Baylor basketball players.

Dennehy was reported missing by his family June 19, and his sport utility vehicle, its license plates missing, was found last week in a mall parking lot in Virginia Beach.

Melis said officers were treating the disappearance like a homicide because his department got a call “from an outside source” that said a homicide had occurred in the Waco area and the victim could be associated with a local university.

Dennehy transferred to Baylor in hopes of making what he called a fresh start after getting kicked off the team at New Mexico because of his temper.

The 6-foot-10, 230-pound center accepted a scholarship to play basketball at the Baptist school and told friends he had become a born-again Christian. He was a B student and rarely missed a class.

“It’s a fresh start,” he said when accepting a scholarship in May 2002. “I feel great. It’s a new coach, a new team, a new set of personalities.”

Over the weekend, Baylor coach Dave Bliss called Dennehy “a gem” and said: “The team, the university and all the members of the Baylor family and myself are in tremendous disbelief. … No part really seems real.”

Baylor athletic director Tom Stanton said yesterday he couldn’t discuss the case. He also added that he wanted to stop some of the “negative suggestions about [Dennehys] temperament.”

“We saw a young man who got along well with his teammates and was extremely anxious to compete this year,” Stanton said. “Patrick has been a model student-athlete since coming to Baylor. That’s why these incredible events have stunned and upset us all.”

Kristal Wilson, 21, a senior from El Paso, lives next door to the four-bedroom apartment that she said Dennehy, Dotson and another person shared. She said they were well-mannered and sometimes played loud music, which was typical in the complex.

“They were just really funny guys,” she said, fighting back tears. “I’m sure it’s upsetting for everybody. It’s a tragedy.”

Before he disappeared, Dennehy was attending summer school at Baylor, the world’s largest Baptist university with more than 14,000 students.

At Baylor, he was not eligible to play basketball for a year, but he practiced with the team and sat on the bench during games.

The junior from Santa Clara, Calif., majored in speech communication and dreamed of playing in the NBA, then working in public relations for his favorite team, the Sacramento Kings, said John Cunningham, a speech communications professor at Baylor.

When Dennehy did not call home on Father’s Day, June 15, his mother, Valorie Brabazon, and his stepfather, Brian Brabazon, got worried. When Dennehy’s girlfriend called his parents looking for him, they started calling his friends.

What the stepfather found out — he will not give details — upset him so much he decided to call the university.

Brabazon also said someone had recently broken into Dennehy’s SUV and stolen money from him and that Dennehy had told Baylor coaches he was scared.

Dennehy played two seasons at New Mexico, where he averaged 10.6 points and 7.5 rebounds as a sophomore and was named honorable mention All-Mountain West Conference in 2001-02.

He was removed from the team after losing his temper during practice, less than two weeks after he argued with a teammate during a game, kicked a chair and stormed out.

Team doctors said a medical condition may have contributed to the outburst but would not say what it was.

Dotson, a 6-foot-7 forward, averaged 4.6 points and 2.5 rebounds in a reserve role with Baylor last season. He was not expected to return next season.

He came to Baylor after spending two seasons at Paris Junior College, where he attended after originally signing with the University of Buffalo out of high school. He never went to Buffalo.

Sign up for Daily Newsletters

Manage Newsletters

Copyright © 2020 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.


Click to Read More and View Comments

Click to Hide