- The Washington Times - Monday, March 24, 2003

US Airways and its pilots union reached an agreement on an underfunded pension plan during the weekend, clearing a critical hurdle to the air carrier's emergence from bankruptcy protection to free more than $1 billion in financing.
Arlington-based US Airways' efforts to eliminate its pension obligations have sent a chill through the retired pilots, whose lifestyles could be altered for the rest of their lives.
The airline has sought to restructure the pilots' pension plan to reduce its costs. Under the existing plan, the airline estimates, it will have to contribute $1.6 billion during the next seven years to keep the plan solvent.
The company believes it can afford to contribute about $850 million. It has proposed canceling the existing plan and using the $850 million to start a smaller plan.
The agreement on a new program was made Saturday between US Airways and the master executive council of the Air Line Pilots Association, both parties' Web sites said. Details were not disclosed. The revised plan requires the approval of the federal Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp., which guarantees employer pensions.
Spokesmen for US Airways and the union did not return telephone messages yesterday.
The stock market's poor performance the past three years has withered many companies' investments, leaving them with pension-fund deficits that are cutting away at profits.
US Airways' retirees have been worried that they will lose a chunk of the regular benefit checks they will receive for the rest of their lives.
One of them is Wayne Grimes, a 63-year-old pilot who retired from US Airways after 30 years and lives with his wife in Moneta, Va.
"It's kind of taking away my play money," Mr. Grimes said before the deal was announced. "I was counting on this money for extra things around the house here and vacations. We're definitely going to have to cut back on those things."
Mr. Grimes considers himself lucky compared with some pilots. He has opted to take 75 percent of his retirement benefits in a lump sum and the rest in an annuity that gives him monthly checks.
Some retired pilots chose to take all their benefits as annuities, which means they risk losing much of their $75,000 to $80,000 per year in payments.
Retired US Airways pilots have organized an association they call the Soaring Eagles.
Tom Davis, the group's spokesman, said some of his fellow retired pilots who depend on annuities are becoming despondent.
"Their life insurance has been canceled, and their health benefits have been changed twice in the last six months," he said. "They are selling their assets. Their own personal feeling is that they should have done better at managing their personal affairs."
US Airways officials say they are merely confronting difficult realities.
Replacing the pilots' pension plan is "critical to the company emerging from Chapter 11" bankruptcy protection, spokesman David Castelveter said.
"It is the only time we have been in this situation," he said. "It was predicated mostly because of the market conditions stemming from the horrific events of September 11."
Many companies and retirees face similar problems.
General Motors Corp. said its pension plan ended the year with a $19.3 billion deficit, although the company contributed $2.6 billion to it.
Costs of the GM pension are expected to triple this year, resulting in lower profits for the company.
Ford Motor Co. contributed a half-billion dollars this year and expects to make another half-billion dollar contribution. IBM Corp. put $4 billion into its pension funds in December. Honeywell International and Johnson & Johnson also have made large contributions recently.
The airline industry is one of the hardest-hit by the high cost of pension funds.
Delta Air Lines and airplane manufacturer Boeing Co. have reduced their estimates of their net worth because of their pension liabilities. The reduction in valuation hurts the companies' ability to secure financing. Delta was forced to renegotiate contracts with its lenders after the devaluation.
Executives of United Airlines, which is trying to emerge from bankruptcy, plan to ask a bankruptcy court for authority to terminate labor agreements, which would include pensions.
"It's definitely a cost for us," said United Airlines spokesman Jeff Green, referring to the pensions. "We're trying to get all costs down."
The federal Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp. (PBGC) estimates that employer pension funds are underfunded by more than $300 billion.
Steven Kandarian, the agency's executive director, recently told Congress that the PBGC has used up its $7.7 billion surplus, which is supposed to be a backstop for private pension funds, because it has had to secure funds from companies with serious financial problems, particularly in the airline and steel industries.
Current laws are "inadequate to fully protect the pensions of America's workers when their plans terminate," Mr. Kandarian told the Senate Finance Committee.
About 44 million Americans qualify for pension benefits. Their numbers are expected to grow as baby boomers retire.
The minimum funding requirements for employers "are simply not high enough for the plans of companies at the greatest risk of termination," Mr. Kandarian said.
The PBGC guarantees pensions by charging premiums to employers or their investment funds. If an employer fails in its pension obligations, the PBGC is supposed to take over the fund and continue paying benefits. The agency receives no tax money.
One needed change is the way companies compute their contribution requirements, Mr. Kandarian said. They base their contributions on average earnings from previous years. A bad year results in a low contribution to a pension fund.
The Bush administration is proposing changes to the program, but some providers say no regulatory change is needed. They say patience and the next bull market will erase the underfunding problems.
"Over time these things will be resolved," said Toni Simonetti, General Motors spokeswoman. "We've been in these situations before."
This article is based in part on wire service reports.

Copyright © 2019 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

The Washington Times Comment Policy

The Washington Times welcomes your comments on Spot.im, our third-party provider. Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.


Click to Read More and View Comments

Click to Hide