- The Washington Times - Wednesday, February 1, 2006


Lawmakers yesterday accused Internet companies of giving in to pressure from China and helping to censor Internet users in violation of U.S. principles of free speech.

They also criticized the four companies — Microsoft Corp., Yahoo Inc., Cisco Systems Inc. and Google Inc. — for failing to attend a congressional briefing that was held to explain how Internet companies conduct business in China.

Microsoft and Yahoo issued a joint statement that, by themselves, they lack the leverage to influence world governments. The statement suggested that the four companies could work together with governments to better protect the interests of all Internet services.

“There has been a string of disturbing incidents in which U.S.-based Internet companies have bowed to pressure from Beijing,” said Rep. Tom Lantos, California Democrat and co-chairman of the Congressional Human Rights Caucus.

He said that instead of using their resources to develop new technologies to bypass government gatekeepers, the Internet companies have agreed to guard the gates themselves.

Google provoked criticism last week by starting a new search engine in China that will censor some results to comply with the country’s free-speech restrictions. The search engines block Web sites that discuss the Tiananmen Square massacre and Falun Gong spiritual movement, among other topics.

Reporters Without Borders, an advocacy group, said it had proved that Yahoo helped the Chinese police identify and convict Shi Tao, a journalist who criticized human rights abuses in China.

“These massively successful high-tech companies, which couldn’t bring themselves to send representatives to this meeting today, should be ashamed. They caved in to Beijing for the sake of profits,” said Mr. Lantos, the top Democrat on the House International Relations Committee.

Rep. Tim Ryan, Ohio Democrat, said U.S. companies will continue to expand in the Chinese market, “but they should not let profits take precedence over traditional democratic values such as freedom of speech.”

Although Beijing has supported Internet use for education and business, it fiercely polices the Internet’s content. Filters block objectionable foreign Web sites, and regulations ban what the Chinese consider subversive and pornographic content and require service providers to enforce censorship.

Foreign companies have adopted Chinese standards, saying they must obey local laws.

In their statement, Microsoft and Yahoo said they wanted to assure lawmakers and the public “that we do not consider the Internet situation in China to be one of ‘business as usual.’”

Carolyn Bartholomew, acting chairwoman of the U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission, a congressionally mandated monitoring group, said China has begun to assume the role of technological leader among the developing nations in its region.

“China serves as the regional Internet provider for surrounding oppressive regimes, including North Korea and Uzbekistan,” she said. “Through this role as Internet gatekeeper, China exports its filtering technologies to other governments that may choose to employ them.”

While attendance at yesterday’s briefing was not mandatory, companies could be compelled with subpoenas to attend a Feb. 15 hearing on the issue, said Rep. Christopher Smith, New Jersey Republican and chairman of the House International Relations Africa, global human rights and international operations subcommittee.

He criticized U.S. Internet companies in an interview, saying they were helping China arrest and torture activists and screen information from its citizens.

“This is not benign or neutral,” Mr. Smith said of companies acceding to China’s demands. “They have an obligation not to be promoting dictatorship.”

Microsoft, Cisco and Google said they planned to attend the Feb. 15 hearing. Yahoo did not respond to messages seeking comment.

Sign up for Daily Newsletters

Manage Newsletters

Copyright © 2020 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.


Click to Read More and View Comments

Click to Hide