- The Washington Times - Friday, April 10, 2009

ALBANY, N.Y. (AP) - A prominent thoroughbred breeder who once owned a Kentucky Derby favorite was charged Friday with cruelty to animals, two days after authorities seized 177 malnourished horses at his Hudson Valley farm.

Ernie Paragallo was charged with 22 counts of violating New York’s Agriculture and Markets law that prohibits torturing or injuring an animal or failing to provide sustenance, New York state police dispatcher Terri Gallagher said.

After Paragallo’s arrest, New York State Racing and Wagering Board chairman John Sabini released a statement saying the board had “immediately terminated his privilege to be involved with thoroughbred racing in New York.”

The 51-year-old Paragallo was arraigned before Coxsackie Town Justice Thomas Fori and sent to the Greene County Jail in lieu of $5,000 cash or $10,000 bond bail.

He did not immediately return a message left on his cell phone after his arrest.

Paragallo, the owner of 1996 Derby favorite and fifth-place finisher Unbridled’s Song, was arrested after driving upstate from his Long Island home to be questioned by investigators about the malnourished horses found Wednesday on his Center Brook farm. The farm is in Greene County, 20 miles south of Albany.

“It wasn’t knowing neglect,” Paragallo told The Associated Press. “Did I try and harm any of those horses? Absolutely not. Did some of them come up skinny? Absolutely. Was it mismanagement? Absolutely. I’m not shying away from it. But I didn’t abuse them.”

State police and animal protection organizations seized the horses at his upstate farm. Veterinarians examined the animals and found all of them to be in varying stages of malnutrition.

The horses remain on the farm under the supervision of the Columbia Greene Humane Society, which has brought in hay and grain for them. Paragallo agreed Friday to transfer ownership of 67 of the horses to the humane society for future adoption.

Ron Perez, president of the humane society, said that in addition to being malnourished, many of the horses were infested with internal and external parasites, suffering from untreated lacerations, and in need of hoof care. He said broodmares were kept in stalls without proper bedding.

“This is a sad situation for the animals,” Perez said. “The way he let them go is absolutely unconscionable.”

Paragallo blamed the horses’ conditions on miscalculations in the amount of feed and hay purchased for the farm over the winter.

“We probably underfed them the amount of feed they were supposed to get,” he said.

Paragallo said he had even more horses, 240 to 250, the previous winter on the 500-acre farm, which has two 83-acre paddocks.

“It’s hard to keep track of every horse when they’re turned out in those big paddocks,” he said.

Paragallo said he hadn’t visited the farm in at least nine months.

Unbridled’s Song won the 1995 Breeders’ Cup Juvenile, and in ‘96 won the Florida Derby and the Wood Memorial to earn his status as Kentucky Derby favorite. He also owned Artax, the 1999 Eclipse winner as top sprinter.

Meanwhile, the New York Racing Association revoked Paragallo’s credentials for NYRA’s three tracks _ Saratoga, Belmont and Aqueduct, where his daughters’ stable has 40 horses. The move prohibits Paragallo from the tracks’ backstretch and paddock, but not its grandstand or other areas open to patrons.

Paragallo was licensed with the state Racing and Wagering Board as the authorized agent for Paraneck Stable, which he founded but later turned over to his daughters Jennifer and Kristen in 2005, when the state revoked his owner’s license for financial irresponsibility.

NYRA officials said no member of the Paragallo family or current Paraneck employee are allowed to operate the stable. The Paraneck horses currently stabled at Aqueduct’s barns will be allowed to remain at the track. According to the Daily Racing Form, three Paraneck horses set to race at Aqueduct were scratched this week and five others will be scratched between Friday and Wednesday.

Copyright © 2018 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

The Washington Times Comment Policy

The Washington Times welcomes your comments on Spot.im, our third-party provider. Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.


Click to Read More and View Comments

Click to Hide