- The Washington Times - Wednesday, May 13, 2009


This has been a “yeah, but” series for Penguins goaltender Marc-Andre Fleury.

Has he been beaten on several long-range shots by Alex Ovechkin?

Yeah, but that’s Ovechkin. He does it to everyone (Penguins goaltending coach Gilles Meloche said that when he and Fleury look at video of Ovechkin’s goals - even slow-motion video - they often cannot see the puck until it bounces out of the net).

Didn’t the Capitals beat Fleury with two harsh-angle shots in Game 6?

Yeah, but one of them bounced off a Caps player and the other appeared to elude Fleury only because defenseman Hal Gill skated behind him and blocked his path to the opposite post.

Doesn’t Fleury’s sickly series save percentage (.874) pale in comparison with that of Caps goaltender Simeon Varlamov (.907), who has faced 67 more shots?

Yeah, but Varlamov doesn’t have to face Ovechkin, and sometimes it’s easier to stay sharp with a ton of shots.

Play the “yeah, but” game long enough, and you can almost convince yourself that Fleury has been fine.

Well, he hasn’t been fine.

But he can make up for it in Game 7 on Wednesday.

Don’t get me wrong. Fleury has been OK - but only OK. For the most part, he has been the second-best goalie in the series, which wouldn’t be a problem except that only two goalies are playing.

On Tuesday, I took an informal poll of 10 media types, most of whom have played or coached in the NHL, and asked them to rate Fleury’s performance in this series on a scale of one to 10.

Nobody gave him above a 7.

If this were figure skating, he would be crying on his coach’s shoulder.

One observer put it best when he said, “Any other goaltender would have the Penguins at this same point in the series.”

Then again, the Penguins might not be in the second round if not for Fleury - he was the team MVP against the Flyers - and nobody will care what happened in the first six games if he is phenomenal Wednesday, which he likely will need to be.

Asked to rate his play against the Caps, Fleury said: “It’s kind of tough to say. There are a lot of goals, more than I would like. That’s frustrating. At the same time, I watch tape with Gilles, and there’s some bounces they get, some nice goals they get. But definitely, I’d like to make more saves.”

To this point in his playoff career, Fleury, 24, has developed something of a dual personality.

He is brilliant at times and consistently solid for long stretches but can be leaky at the worst moments and has a penchant for yielding the calamitous goal, whether it be a deflection off his runaway stick, a bank shot off his back or an own goal (happened in Game 6 of the Stanley Cup Finals, when Fleury inadvertently knocked in the deciding goal off his backside).

The Caps’ first goal in this series, when the Penguins were dominating them early in Game 1, came when Fleury turned a nonchance (Matt Bradley’s weak attempt from the corner) into a grade-A chance by kicking the puck into the slot.

On the other hand, Fleury has made a number of timely saves. He has a short memory, too, so weird goals and off games don’t tend to linger.

This will be Fleury’s first Game 7 in the NHL. He has delivered some of his greatest postseason performances on the road, Game 5 in Detroit last season and Game 4 against the Flyers this year being prime examples.

Meloche likes Fleury’s chances in Game 7 against the Caps.

“I’m not worried about it,” he said. “I’m sure he’ll be ready.”

Make no mistake, if the Penguins win, it will be because their three biggest stars - Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Fleury - play to the moment.

No ands, ifs or “yeah, buts” about that.

Sign up for Daily Newsletters

Copyright © 2019 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

The Washington Times Comment Policy

The Washington Times welcomes your comments on Spot.im, our third-party provider. Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.


Click to Read More and View Comments

Click to Hide