The long-shot bid by Republicans to retake control of the Senate is suddenly in play, as the prospect of high-profile Republican candidates entering the fray has pushed the GOP even or ahead in polling for 10 races.
The potential candidacies of former Republican Govs. George E. Pataki in New York and Tommy G. Thompson in Wisconsin are improving the polling fortunes of the party as it pursues seats long in the hands of Democrats, while the anti-government “tea party” movement has provided momentum to Republican challengers in states such as Florida, Arkansas and Pennsylvania.
“If the election were held today, the Republicans could come close to winning back the Senate, if not actually win it,” said pollster John Zogby.
Republicans are solidly ahead to take at least five seats now held by Democrats — in North Dakota, Delaware, Nevada, Arkansas and Pennsylvania. Five more are now considered winnable — Colorado, Illinois, Wisconsin, Indiana and even liberal New York. Two other races, in California and Washington, are tightening daily.
TWT RELATED STORIES:
• Obama critics mobilize to restore budget cuts
• Budget-strapped states avoid the word ‘taxes’
• Obama eyes bailout cash for small loans
• Terrorist attempt ‘certain’ within months
• Gates to Hill: Pentagon to ease gay ban
• Germany pursues tax evaders’ data
In Wisconsin, three-term Democratic Sen. Russ Feingold suddenly faces a real contest from Mr. Thompson — who has not even decided whether to enter the race. The most recent poll from Rasmussen Reports found Mr. Thompson leading Mr. Feingold by a 47 percent to 43 percent margin. Independent voters favored Mr. Thompson 53 percent to 36 percent, the survey found.
Independents are credited with putting Republican Scott Brown over the finish line last month to win a U.S. Senate seat from Massachusetts occupied for 47 years by liberal icon Edward M. Kennedy.
In New York, freshman Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, a Democrat, trails Mr. Pataki by 2.7 percentage points, according to an average of all polls compiled by the Web site Real Clear Politics. The latest survey by Marist put the ex-governor up by six percentage points, a change from a January poll by the organization, which found a three-percentage-point edge for Mrs. Gillibrand.
The formidable New York Republican also has not decided to throw his hat into the ring, a fact some analysts say could well hamper Republican hopes to retake the Senate.
“Now? No. Absolutely not,” said Stuart Rothenberg, editor and publisher of the Rothenberg Political Report. Republicans “would need top-tier candidates in places like Wisconsin, Indiana, Washington and New York, and after that, they would need everything to fall in place.”
“Right now, they don’t have serious opportunities in 10 states with Democratic-held Senate seats up this cycle,” he said.
Mr. Zogby, like many election analysts and pollsters, pointed out that the election is months away, and noted that Republicans would have to hold each of their 18 seats on the ballot this fall and pick up 10 of 16 contested Democratic seats.
“If the Senate elections were held right now, Republicans would have a chance — a small chance — of capturing a Senate majority,” said Michael Barone, a political analyst and co-author of “The Almanac of American Politics.”
“Just about every close race would have to go their way. It would be the equivalent of drawing an inside straight, or even more unlikely.”
Complicating the equation even more, six Republican senators have announced that they are not running for re-election, and Democrats have a reasonable chance of picking up seats in New Hampshire, Florida, Kentucky and Missouri.
Still, many observers see a trend in favor of Republicans.
“If a Republican can win in a fairly high-turnout election … in Massachusetts, is there anywhere they can’t win?” analyst Sean Trende wrote on the Real Clear Politics Web site.
The emerging power of the tea party movement, which organized large, grass-roots demonstrations over the summer, combined with the populist message that put Mr. Brown into office, has changed the dynamic of this year’s midterm elections. The fact the Republicans are polling well in Democratic strongholds such as Wisconsin, New York and even Washington state — where the only poll taken so far shows Sen. Patty Murray leading by just two percentage points — has worried some Democrats.
“In the wake of [Mr. Brown’s] win in Massachusetts, a notable proportion — 45 percent — of registered Democratic voters in New York state say they are worried that a Republican will defeat the state’s Democratic senators running for office in November,” the New York Marist poll said.
Other states are also newly in play. In Indiana, two-term Sen. Evan Bayh finds himself in a tightening race. The latest Rasmussen poll showed Mr. Bayh, a moderate Democrat who voted for President Obama’s health care overhaul bill, trailing Republican Rep. Mike Pence by three percentage points. Mr. Pence last week decided not to run, but other Republicans are lining up to take on Mr. Bayh, who is polling at less than 50 percent against two other possible Republican challengers.
Another Democratic seat now in play is Mr. Obama’s former seat in Illinois. His appointed replacement, Roland W. Burris, is not seeking election, and polls ahead of Tuesday’s primary showed moderate Republican Rep. Mark Steven Kirk, a Navy reservist who recently returned from a deployment to Afghanistan, running strongly against any likely Democratic opponent.
The political atmosphere in Colorado also has changed sharply. The latest poll by Daily Kos, a liberal Web site, gave a one-point edge to freshman Sen. Michael Bennet, a Democrat, but recent polls by Rasmussen show former Lt. Gov. Jane Norton, a Republican, with a 12-point lead over the incumbent.
Some analysts said that turning the Senate contests into a vote of confidence on the Democratic majorities in Congress could be a winning strategy this fall for the Republicans, especially among independents.
“The best thing the GOP can do is to keep the election as a referendum on the Democrats, rather than a choice between the parties,” said pollster Scott Rasmussen. “Unaffiliated voters voted against the party in power during 2006 and 2008. They did so again in 2009, and appear poised to do so in 2010.”
Mr. Zogby said Republicans “are at the mercy of the economy.”
“If there is any uptick in employment or other key indicators, the administration can claim success,” he said.
On Monday, the Obama administration predicted little improvement in the nation’s job situation. The forecast was a 9.8 percent unemployment rate at the end of this year, down only slightly from the current rate of 10 percent.
Even if Republicans do not take back control of the Senate this year, the outcome could serve them well.
“I’m not sure that Republicans want to win control in 2010,” Mr. Rasmussen said. “It would probably be better for them to get close in this cycle and leave the Democrats on top heading into 2012. The Senate lineup that year will give Republicans plenty of opportunities.”