OPINION:
The investigation into the death of former Russian intelligence officer Alexander Litvinenko, who died after being exposed to radioactive polonium-210 in London, hit a wall when Moscow refused to hand over the man British prosecutors believe responsible for his death. In demanding that Russia extradite Andrei Lugovoi, British authorities took a stand and sent a firm message that the murder of Mr. Litvinenko would not pass quietly. Moscow was angry: Russia’s foreign minister denounced the request as “political,” and President Vladimir Putin called it “stupidity.” Russia’s constitution officially bars the extradition of its citizens, but were Moscow inclined to send Mr. Lugovoi to London to stand trial, the 1957 European Convention on Extradition, which Russia signed, could plausibly provide the legal framework to do so.
Russia, however, officially denied Britain’s extradition request last week. On Monday, four Russian diplomats were expelled from London — only the beginning of Britain’s response, according to Foreign Secretary David Miliband — setting the stage for a reprisal and portending a downturn in already chilly British-Russian relations. For Gordon Brown, only three weeks into his tenure as British prime minister, it is an early challenge. British authorities have a very serious criminal case to deal with, and a quick consideration of the unsatisfactory Russian handling of other murder cases — ranging from Paul Klebnikov to Anna Politkovskaya — makes it clear that when it comes to justice, Moscow is not a suitable substitute for London. Britain should continue to emphasize that this is a criminal investigation and seek Russia’s cooperation.
The Litvinenko case is set in the context of generally deteriorating relations between Russia and the West, and that has made the affair more divisive than it needed to be. Over the weekend, for instance, Russia declared its intention to suspend participation in the Treaty on Conventional Armed Forces in Europe, effective approximately five months down the road. At issue, ostensibly, is NATO’s refusal to accept updates to the treaty until Russia removes troops from Georgia and Moldova. Russia has also charged that NATO expansion in Eastern Europe violates the provisions of the treaty — a claim U.S. officials contest. It’s hard, however, not to see this as yet another example of Mr. Putin further removing Russia from the West’s sphere of influence.
People were interested in these podcasts
Mr. Putin is unaccustomed to such a direct rebuke from the West. How Mr. Putin responds to the expulsion of his diplomats from London will determine whether the dispute over the murder suspect will escalate, and to what degree. Although Russian officials shift the blame to their British counterparts, the damage done by Moscow’s obstruction in the Litvinenko case impedes cooperation that would be mutually beneficial. Russia needs to ask whether a foreign policy that undermines its own self-interest can serve any real purpose.
Please read our comment policy before commenting.