Vietnam replays

• Article
• Comments ()
• Click-2-Listen
• Videos

By

John Forbes Kerry seldom misses an opportunity to bring up the subject of his Vietnam War experiences.

"It is hard still to explain the clashing feelings," Mr. Kerry wrote in the New York Times the other day. "There was [sic] the deep and enduring bonds forged among crewmates, brothers in arms from all walks of life fighting each day to keep faith with one another on a tiny boat on the rivers of the Mekong Delta. And there was the anger I felt toward body-counting, face-saving leaders sitting safely in Washington sending to the killing fields troops who were often poor, black or brown."

Anybody who lived through the Vietnam era can understand the conflicted feelings about that war. Nor can one doubt that Lt. j.g. Kerry served honorably and well aboard his swift boat in the Mekong River Delta, bringing home a Silver Star, a Bronze Star and three Purple Hearts for wounds in battle.

But as others have noted, the Vietnam War was fought at home as well as abroad. And legitimate questions can be asked about the honor -- or dishonor -- of John Kerry's stateside experiences after returning from Vietnam.

In January 1971, Detroit was the site of the so-called Winter Soldiers Investigation, in which Mr. Kerry and others, financed by Jane Fonda and other far-left activists, sought not just to protest the war but to make the case America had become an Evil Empire that systematically looted, raped, killed and tortured its enemies.

Scores of supposed Vietnam vets were paraded before the cameras to proffer lurid accounts about what had gone on. Several days later Mr. Kerry, as leader of Vietnam Veterans Against the War, would assure Congress that "these were not isolated events but crimes committed on a day-to-day basis with the full awareness of officers at all levels of command."

The vets, Mr. Kerry told a rapt audience in Washington, "told stories that at times they had personally raped, cut off ears, cut off heads, taped wires from portable telephones to human genitals, cut off limbs, blown up bodies, randomly shot at civilians, razed villages in a fashion reminiscent of Genghis Khan... and generally ravaged the countryside."

But as Vietnam combat platoon leader and military researcher B.J. Burkett and investigative reporter Glenna Whitney point out in "Stolen Valor," a systematic look at the claims of VVAW and other antiwar groups, federal investigators were stonewalled when they tried to follow up on the claims.

Many of the stories were later shown to be fictional. Other so-called Vietnam veterans, such as the executive secretary of VVAW, Al Hubbard, a self-styled poet ("See what you've become, Amerika," ends one of his Vietnam odes), turned out to have no record of service in Vietnam.