Former reporter Mudd upon news

This is a column about Roger Mudd, so let’s not beat around the bush. How does he feel now that his old rival Dan Rather is preparing to step down as anchor of the “CBS Evening News” under the darkest of clouds?

“Dan has gone more places and worked harder and done more in that job than any of the other anchors,” Mr. Mudd said from a corner table at one of his regular haunts, a French bistro near his McLean home.

“For whatever reasons in his background, education, upbringing, he’s had this compulsion to prove himself. He spread himself too thin.”

Mr. Mudd was referring, of course, to Mr. Rather’s role in the flawed “60 Minutes Wednesday” report on President Bush’s National Guard service. The Sept. 8 piece was based on memos that weren’t adequately authenticated.

Last month, the independent panel that investigated the flap concluded that Mr. Rather was overworked and contributed little to the memo story.

The investigators also said they uncovered no evidence of political bias at CBS, which Mr. Mudd believes.

Although Mr. Mudd keeps his politics private, his deep devotion to family and faith has led some to suspect that he leans to the right. Regardless, he said there was no liberal tilt at CBS when he worked there from 1961 until 1980.

But enough about Dan Rather. This is a column about Roger Mudd, after all, and he has plenty to say about a profession he helped shape at CBS, when he was the best TV reporter on Capitol Hill.

His biggest gripe: TV reporting on Congress lacks depth. He cited last month’s coverage of Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice’s Senate confirmation hearings as an example.

“Just to run clips of a Q-and-A [between Miss Rice and a senator] doesn’t give any context,” he said.

Then there was the quote CBS Senior Vice President Marcy McGinnis gave The Washington Post last week, defending her network’s dearth of overseas bureaus: “You don’t have to live in Moscow to be able to go cover Moscow.”

Mr. Mudd’s reaction: “What … is she talking about?”

He was equally inflamed when CBS Chairman Leslie Moonves told reporters last month that the concept of a single anchor with the “voice of God” was outdated. Mr. Mudd said the remark “throws into the trash can decades of tradition.”

But Mr. Mudd is no grumpy old man.

At 76, he looks older than most viewers probably remember, but he is as urbane as ever in his turtleneck and sport coat.

Story Continues →