Mideast Humpty Dumpty

• Article
• Comments ()
• Click-2-Listen
• Videos

By

A small army of Middle Eastern experts, former ambassadors to Israel and/or Arab capitals, think tank specialists, special envoys under the last five administrations, former secretaries of state, European Union foreign affairs ministers, all have urged rapid resumption of negotiations between Israelis and Palestinians. They perceive a golden opportunity with a near perfect alignment of favorable stars that seem to bode well for peace.

The stars are the peaceful elections for a new Palestinian leader; the prospect of a fresh Likud-Labor coalition in Israel that should temper Prime Minister Ariel Sharon's hawkish policies; a forthcoming Israeli withdrawal from Gaza; and a U.S. president who can rebuild Arab trust since he need not worry about re-election, which means he can afford to displease the powerful Israeli lobby, now under FBI investigation for alleged receipt of top secret Pentagon documents.

Alas, Middle Eastern political forecasting invariably seems to make astrology look respectable.

After the next round of jaw-jaw, a viable Palestinian state will still be as elusive as before. The Palestinians have a new leader to replace Abu Ammar, the nom de guerre of the late Yasser Arafat. And if President Mahmoud Abbas (a k a Abu Mazen) can dodge what are bound to be multiple assassination plots and attempts on his life, he may still emerge a voice for reason.

But reason in Palestinian parlance does not mean accepting a less than viable state. Mr. Abbas will still have to contend with extremists from Hamas, Hezbollah and Islamic Jihad. Fatah militants from his own party have already challenged him. And the common thread among all his detractors, who look forward to the day between 2010 and 2015 when there will be more Arabs than Jews between the Mediterranean and the Jordan River, is opposition to Israel's very existence.

Mr. Abbas wears a suit in sharp contrast with Arafat's fatigues and checkered keffyah headdress. But an Arafat crony, Mr. Abbas has a checkered past, including a Holocaust denial doctoral dissertation linking Zionism and Nazism (which he later recanted as the lucubrations of an immature youth). During the election campaign, he still called Israel "the Zionist enemy."

On the Israeli side, only a few months ago Mr. Sharon's former chief of staff and close friend Dov Weisglass confirmed what had long been denied: the policy is a subterfuge to pre-empt a Palestinian state by ensuring its stillbirth. Thus, the two-state solution Mr. Bush advocates was dead on arrival. Mr. Sharon has now asked Mr. Weisglass to be his link with Mr. Abbas.

At the very least, a "viable" state means (1) a West Bank free of most of Israel's 140 settlements, where some 240,000 Israeli settlers are still building and expanding, and (2) a capital in Arab East Jerusalem, now isolated and deprived by Israeli settlements of direct access to West Bank Palestinian towns.

Then there is the $2 billion combined wall-cum-ditch-cum-electrified fence that snakes deep into the West Bank to (1) keep terrorists out of Israel and (2) protect Israeli settlements close to the old pre-1967 war border.

Gaza, shorn of Israeli settlements, would remain under Israeli control. IDF troops will continue surrounding Gaza and controlling its airport and seaport.