- ISIL creates all-female brigade to terrorize women into following Sharia law
- ISTOOK: Obama wants to be impeached
- Obama to Latin leaders: Help with border
- Military bans troops from Baptist church event honoring ‘God’s Rescue Squad’
- ‘Pocket drones’: U.S. Army developing tiny surveillance tools for the next big war
- Belgian cafe posts sign: Dogs allowed, but Jews stay out
- Gen. Dempsey: Pentagon studying Russian readiness plans not viewed ‘for 20 years’
- John McCain: Botched, two-hour execution of murderer is ‘torture’
- House GOP ready to move border bill
- Bomb squad called after live WWII artillery washes on Cape Cod beach
The 4th Circuit
Question of the Day
Change is coming to a pillar of American constitutionalist jurisprudence. The 4th Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond, widely regarded as the most conservative federal appellate court in the country and the site of Judges Terrence W. Boyle’s and William J. Haynes II’s confirmation battles, could soon be one-third vacant.
Of 15 total seats, there are three longstanding and well-publicized vacancies, a fourth in the not-too-distant future when Judge H. Emory Widener retires and now a fifth. Three weeks ago, Chief Judge William W. Wilkins, a Reagan appointee, announced plans to assume “senior status,” a kind of working retirement, in mid-2007. Minus those two judges, the court will consist of six Republican appointees and four Democrats. If one counts Judge Roger L. Gregory among the Democrats — he is a 2000 Bill Clinton recess appointee renominated by President Bush and confirmed in 2000 — then the court is evenly split 5-5. It’s also worth mentioning the loss of Judge J. Michael Luttig, a towering conservative intellect, whose unusual departure to become senior vice president of Boeing Co. this year took most by surprise and stripped the court of a key figure.
Presuming a Democratic Senate through 2008 and a 50-50 chance of a Democratic presidential victory thereafter, at least some of this court’s distinctive conservatism is in danger of being lost, possibly even most of it. That would happen if Republicans cannot fill these seats before late 2008 and then end up losing the presidential election. The party needs to weigh the consequences of that outcome as fully as possible.
A liberal 4th Circuit the last few years would have seriously complicated the Bush administration’s prosecution of the war on terror and also would have deprived conservatives of several significant jurisprudential victories. This is the court that laid much of the legal groundwork for the administration’s policy on detainees (although it sided against the administration a year ago in the case of accused terrorist Jose Padilla).
One obvious solution is to nominate as many moderate, confirmable conservatives as possible now to avoid disaster after 2008. That would mean an end to the days of nominations like Judges Boyle and Haynes, so loathed by liberals. This will no doubt be a bitter pill for Republicans to swallow. But the party should debate the question now, thoroughly, also giving due consideration to the alternative, which is to continue pressing jurists who raise the hackles of liberals in full knowledge that they will fail.
When it comes to the 4th Circuit, the unusually high number of openings at a relatively unfavorable time for Republicans makes this either the end of an era or a substantially new chapter in the current one. It’s time to figure out how to proceed.
President wants everyone but himself to pay more
- ISTOOK: Obama wants to be impeached
- 'We're coming for you, Barack Obama': Top U.S. official discloses threat from ISIL terrorists
- NAPOLITANO: What if our democracy is a fraud?
- 'Pocket drones': U.S. Army developing tiny spies for the next big war
- Russia shipping sophisticated weapons systems to Ukraine separatists
- Michelle Obama says money in politics is bad, asks donors for 'big, fat check'
- CARSON: Costco and the perils of politicizing business
- Ohio university quiz implies atheists are naturally smarter than Christians
- EDITORIAL: Detroit's water 'spigot bigots'
- Brian Kelly, Notre Dame ready for different route to title
Obama's biggest White House 'fails'
Celebrities turned politicians
Athletes turned actors
20 gadgets that changed the world
Fighting in Iraq